Best 1911 manufacturer? - Page 5 - TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
Judge Smails
LA-Monroe Fan
Native Son of NELA
Member since Mar 2008
4321 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


quote:

Colt won the Marine Corps 1911 contract


Slight hijack, but a Marine 1911 csb... My buddy buys a Colt Special Combat Government off gunbroker. When he receives it it has the wrong box as well as different grips and night sites. He calls Colt and they tell him to send the entire pistol back and they will refit it in the Custom Shop (the Special Combat Government is a custom shop gun). He says I'll save everybody some trouble and keep this one if you'll sell me a Marine 1911. Needless to say, he receives it next week.






Back to top
LSUnowhas2
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2004
21818 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


Then why are you attacking/questioning my post touting Vickers when you have your own version of Vickers in Hilton Yam?

I will admit I don't know anything about Hilton Yam.






Back to top
Judge Smails
LA-Monroe Fan
Native Son of NELA
Member since Mar 2008
4321 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


quote:

Vickers


I don't have a dog in the fight but if the guy is on Wilson's payroll wouldn't he be obligated (by financial reasons)to say they make the best product?






Back to top
Dez
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Jun 2007
1611 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


The way I'm reading him is that one man's opinion (no matter who that man is), is just an opinion. It is not concrete evidence that
quote:

Wilson Combat and it isn't even close.






Back to top
VetteGuy
LSU Fan
Mandeville
Member since Feb 2008
11365 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


quote:

Slight hijack, but a Marine 1911 csb... My buddy buys a Colt Special Combat Government off gunbroker. When he receives it it has the wrong box as well as different grips and night sites. He calls Colt and they tell him to send the entire pistol back and they will refit it in the Custom Shop (the Special Combat Government is a custom shop gun). He says I'll save everybody some trouble and keep this one if you'll sell me a Marine 1911. Needless to say, he receives it next week.


Dang!

Very CSB.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
LSUnowhas2
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2004
21818 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


quote:

I don't have a dog in the fight but if the guy is on Wilson's payroll wouldn't he be obligated (by financial reasons)to say they make the best product?


Which is why I brought up the chicken or the egg. It is my understanding that he was touting WC before they ever paid him to do so. It makes sense that they would put him on the payroll.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
LSUnowhas2
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2004
21818 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


quote:

The way I'm reading him is that one man's opinion (no matter who that man is), is just an opinion. It is not concrete evidence that


But my point was that the opinion of a guy like Vickers means more than just some guy that happens to like 1911's. Take it or leave it but I respect Vickers' opinion.






Back to top
VetteGuy
LSU Fan
Mandeville
Member since Feb 2008
11365 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


quote:

Take it or leave it but I respect Vickers' opinion.


I see what you're saying; Vickers would be considered an "expert witness", basically.

Certainly his background would give weight to his remarks.






Back to top
Dez
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Jun 2007
1611 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


quote:

But my point was that the opinion of a guy like Vickers means more than just some guy that happens to like 1911's. Take it or leave it but I respect Vickers' opinion.


That's fine. The problem is the word "best" is a very hard thing to argue when talking about something like this.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
LSUnowhas2
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2004
21818 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


quote:

VetteGuy


thread hijack but I noticed your username which happens to be my other interest. What Vette(s) do you own? I am restoring a C1 right now.






Back to top
chrisman17
New Orleans, LA
Member since Dec 2007
923 posts
 Online 

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


quote:

The way I'm reading him is that one man's opinion (no matter who that man is), is just an opinion. It is not concrete evidence that


Ding ding ding!

I'm certainly not attacking you. Sorry if it came off that way. But as a person that has owned at least two of every semi custom maker out there in the last 20 yrs of my 1911 buying, there is nothing Wilson does that makes it hands down the best 1911 in existence. Everyone will have their opinions though.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
VetteGuy
LSU Fan
Mandeville
Member since Feb 2008
11365 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


quote:

I am restoring a C1 right now.


Man, that's pretty cool.

I have an '03 vert.






Back to top
LSUnowhas2
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2004
21818 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


quote:

Man, that's pretty cool.

I have an '03 vert.



Mine needs some work but it is definitely a fun car.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
DLauw
LSU Fan
SWLA
Member since Sep 2011
2190 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


had to post this because i was reading this thread a few days ago and today while working diligently on work stuff my browser somehow, on its own, found Best 1911 Rail Guns at Every Price Point. it was posted on the same day. obviously it's not definitive but it's still a nice list.





Back to top
GREENHEAD22
LSU Fan
LafayettebywayofBush
Member since Nov 2009
8150 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


quote:

I'll use it for home defense

You clearly don't know what you're doing.








Back to top
DrTyger
LSU Fan
Lake Charles
Member since Oct 2009
21414 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


You don't use a nice 1911 for home defense. Not that it wouldn't do the job but do you really want the cops confiscating your baby for evidence?





Back to top
GREENHEAD22
LSU Fan
LafayettebywayofBush
Member since Nov 2009
8150 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


No not a nice one but I have Springfield beside the bed along with three other guns throughout the house. Thought you were saying it isn't a good home defense gun bc of caliber or capacity etc.





Back to top
DrTyger
LSU Fan
Lake Charles
Member since Oct 2009
21414 posts

re: Best 1911 manufacturer?


Oh God no. It's more than adequate.





Back to top
  Replies (0)


Back to top