| Posted by | Message |
Rittdog Member since Oct 2009 6100 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/26/13 at 10:43 pm to Zed)
quote:
. Pitt was terrible, and Fassbender's character annoyed the shite out of me.
Disagree there. Pitt was solid. Although I must admit it seemed like he was playing in a different movie than everyone else until the very end But that was probably what QT intended...Having the American soldiers represent War films of the 40s-60s. Fassbender was tremendous imo. He makes that Tavern scene complete. Probably a top 5 scene in QT movie history. However, the greatness of that scene is why I think Django Unchained is better. Django Unchained's "Dinner table scene" wasnt as good as IB's....but it was of greater importance. It directly involved central characters to the plot....which ultimately led to "Handshake Scene' which kicks the movie into high gear. I cared more about what was going to happen to Waltz, Foxx, Washington....then Fassbender, Stiglitz....only because.. QT didnt feature their characters enough in the movie. IB needed more Basterds in it imo. More Basterds and it probably is my favorite QT of all time.
This post was edited on 2/26 at 10:47 pm
|
| Back to top | |
LoveThatMoney  LSU Fan Who knows where? Member since Jan 2008 3063 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/26/13 at 10:47 pm to tigerbru17)
quote:
How good is Inglorious Basterds?
It's okay. If you like Tarantino, it's enjoyable. I thought it was pretty average, pretty boring in many parts, and often felt disjointed. But Christoph Waltz is wonderful. Full disclosure, though, the only Tarantino flick I like is Pulp Fiction. I've seen Reservoir Dogs, Kill Bill 1 and 2, Inglorious Basterds, as well as Pulp Fiction. The first four I thought were mediocre at best. Particularly upon second watch.
|
| Back to top | |
Zed  Alabama Fan Member since Feb 2010 5718 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/26/13 at 10:48 pm to Carson123987)
quote:
what did you expect
He really was atrocious, and I like Pitt. Very good in 12 Monkeys and Fight Club. He was hilarious in Burn After Reading.quote:
come on!! he was the shite
His British gentleman act was awful to me. I'm not sure if it was his acting or the character. The scenes with Schultz and Laurent were great.
|
| Back to top | |
Zed  Alabama Fan Member since Feb 2010 5718 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/26/13 at 10:52 pm to Rittdog)
quote:
Fassbender was tremendous imo.
I really didn't like how he played the character. The dialogue was great as usual but Pitt especially didn't get it done for me. The casting for Django was exceptional, and I wouldn't replace anyone except maybe Kerry Washington.
|
| Back to top | |
Jim Rockford  LSU Fan Member since May 2011 23241 posts
Online

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/26/13 at 10:59 pm to tigerbru17)
Tarantino, so overrated.
|
| Back to top | |
Carson123987  LSU Fan Middle Court at The Rec Member since Jul 2011 23154 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/26/13 at 11:05 pm to Jim Rockford)
jim.....
|
| Back to top | |
Rittdog Member since Oct 2009 6100 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/26/13 at 11:20 pm to Zed)
quote:
The casting for Django was exceptional, and I wouldn't replace anyone except maybe Kerry Washington.
Any ideas on who you would replace her with? I thought she did very well with such a small role. Really had to express a lot of emotion without much dialogue.
|
| Back to top | |
Rittdog Member since Oct 2009 6100 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/27/13 at 12:04 am to Carson123987)
quote:
Inglorious Basterds is a far more interesting, smart, and uncompromising movie than the ones that inspired it. Go watch The Dirty Dozen or Where Eagles Dare or Kelly's Heroes or The Great Escape or They Were Expendable and you'll find movies that don't even struggle to rise to the level of meta-commentary on either film as a medium or war or violence; despite comic flourishes, they are earnest and plodding and utterly cliched in their war-is-hell-ain't-it perspective. Even as loopy and uneven a comedy as Kelly's Heroes expects to be taken seriously despite its threadbare messaging and utterly conventional morality. As does Speilberg's Saving Private Ryan, the ending of which is so maudlin and contemptible—Matt Damon's title character demands his family and the audience certify that he'd led a good life—as to erase the power of the film's recreation of the Normandy invasion. Indeed, one of the best ways to view Inglorious Basterds is as a sort of answer movie to the gauzy "Greatest Generation" nostalgia that ultimately undermines Saving Private Ryan.
Now this guy really loves IB. 
|
| Back to top | |
Rittdog Member since Oct 2009 6100 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/27/13 at 12:09 am to Rittdog)
Some more good stuff if you're a fan of QT..
quote:
Tarantino's movies typically pull double duty like the best art always does. Which is to say, they're both interesting in and of themselves while adding on a level of meta-commentary and criticism about how the best art operates. They thus incorporate a faithful evocation of an original while allowing—or forcing—the viewer to think about the generic conventions and cliches we use to convey supposedly unique moments of meaning. Call it the Madame Bovary effect, for Flaubert's masterpiece is ultimately a novel about the effects of novels on people. Or maybe call it The Colbert Report Perplex. Especially at the show's launch, Stephen Colbert's blowhard character was such a perfect distillation of the energy and dynamism and self-importance of Bill O'Reilly that you didn't need to watch The O'Reilly Factor anymore. You could get everything that was truly engaging about O'Reilly—and a comic critique of it—simply by watching Colbert (and note that Colbert pulled this off in large part because his character regularly reduced liberal guests to incoherence by challenging them on their beliefs). Tarantino does something similar in movies such as Django Unchained: He channels past movies but makes something that incorporates their essence while easily surpassing them (if you don't believe that, check out the movie that inspired Tarantino).
|
| Back to top | |
ChewyDante  LSU Fan Member since Jan 2007 7755 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/27/13 at 12:10 am to tigerbru17)
quote:
Inglorious Basterds
Wayyy overrated, but I'm not a Tarantino fan. It really depends on your movie taste.
|
| Back to top | |
Zed  Alabama Fan Member since Feb 2010 5718 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/27/13 at 12:13 am to Rittdog)
quote:
Any ideas on who you would replace her with?
I can't think of anyone really.
|
| Back to top | |
tigerbru17  UTEP Fan Billy in 4C Member since Jan 2009 6627 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/27/13 at 5:15 am to Rittdog)
I rented it and really enjoyed it. Really good movie that I look forward to seeing again. I think the overall story of Django is better, but that's just me. The reason a give the edge to Django is not only the story, but the setting for me was a plus. I have always been more of a civil war guy than a wwII guy. Now my father, he is a big wwII guy so he loves IB. Like I said I really enjoyed this movie and my ranking may change with more views, as I have scene Django twice already.
|
| Back to top | |
Chris4x4gill2  Alabama Fan North Alabama Member since Nov 2008 1492 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/27/13 at 5:52 am to JLSIX)
Love IB. I havent seen Django yet but want to. I will say, I'm a Tarrantino fan, but I did not care for Kill Bill either.
|
| Back to top | |
St Augustine  New Orleans Saints Fan The Pauper of the Surf Member since Mar 2006 36514 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/27/13 at 6:45 am to tigerbru17)
My favorite tarantino movie.
|
| Back to top | |
GetCocky11  South Carolina Fan Columbia, SC Member since Oct 2012 209 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/27/13 at 7:47 am to tigerbru17)
Haven't seen Django yet, but IB was very good I thought. In my opinion, the opening scene is the best part of that entire movie. Very well done. Some of you seemed lukewarm to Kill Bill. I thought Kill Bill Volume 1 was awesome. The length was just right too. However, I have to be in the right mood to watch a Quentin Taratino movie. They tend to be very long movies, and it can get tiring to watch after awhile. Just my opinion. That's why I've never really watched Pulp Fiction or IB more than a couple times.
|
| Back to top | |
Rittdog Member since Oct 2009 6100 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/27/13 at 7:54 am to GetCocky11)
Word is Django Unchained could have been 2 movies. They cut out about 1hr and 20 mins of the story to make it a 2hr 45 minute movie. So it could have been a couple 2 hr movies of Django.. And the timing would have been "just right" for everybody. Which is why it would lessen some of the people's problems with the movie (movie length) Too bad. You should check it out...but yea....it could have been an awesome 2 parter..
|
| Back to top | |
GetCocky11  South Carolina Fan Columbia, SC Member since Oct 2012 209 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/27/13 at 7:59 am to Rittdog)
quote:
Word is Django Unchained could have been 2 movies. They cut out about 1hr and 20 mins of the story to make it a 2hr 45 minute movie. So it could have been a couple 2 hr movies of Django.. And the timing would have been "just right" for everybody. Which is why it would lessen some of the people's problems with the movie (movie length) Too bad. You should check it out...but yea....it could have been an awesome 2 parter..
Which is why I think Kill Bill works. They cut it up into two movies. Sure Volume 2 slightly underwhelmed in the eyes of some I think, but the overall idea worked as a two movie thing. I will absolutely see Django though. QT is a great filmmaker.
This post was edited on 2/27 at 8:01 am
|
| Back to top | |
CocomoLSU  Penn State Fan Inside your dome. Member since Feb 2004 117473 posts
Online

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/27/13 at 8:11 am to tigerbru17)
quote:
I saw the Kill Bills and really did not like Tarentino after that. It just wasn't my thing.
I never wanted to see the KB movies really, because that kind of movie wasn't my thing either. But I found that if you go into them expecting a giant, over-the-top homage to old school martial arts films (which I never watched, but can recognize most of the aspects of), the KB movies are much better. As for how good IB is...it's really good. The dialogue and tension-builds that QT does so well are prevalent throughout the movie. There are some annoying things about it, but all in all, IB is great.
|
| Back to top | |
elprez00  New Orleans Saints Fan Hammond, LA Member since Sep 2011 6175 posts
Online

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/27/13 at 8:24 am to tigerbru17)
IB is fantastic. It's worth watching for Waltz and the Hugo Stiglitz scene alone.
|
| Back to top | |
TigersRuleTheEarth  LA-Lafayette Fan Laffy Member since Jan 2007 26724 posts

| re: How good is Inglorious Basterds? (Posted on 2/27/13 at 8:29 am to tigerbru17)
I never understood the love for IB. I guess I'm going to have to rent it again to see what I missed the first time around.
|
| Back to top | |