Posted byMessage
Taxing Authority
LSU Fan
Houston
Member since Feb 2010
21156 posts

re: Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?


quote:

Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?
Because they've paid into it?

THe better question is why does someone that has never contributed a dime deserve SS at all?






Back to top
FT
Georgia Tech Fan
The University of LSU Fan
Member since Oct 2003
10790 posts

re: Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?


quote:

Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?
Because he's paid into it.






Back to top
austingator
Florida Fan
austin
Member since Jan 2009
5379 posts

re: Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?


quote:

RedShirt Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all? Because he paid into it and deserves like everyone else who did the same thing. Who are you or anyone else to deny him that? WOW!


OPs like this confirm that liberals think money belongs to the state, and there should be redistribution of wealth above everything. They do not understand nor care about the American experiment.






Back to top
Newbomb Turk
Navy Fan
perfectanschlagen
Member since May 2008
9961 posts

re: Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?


Liberals have a problem distinguishing the word "deserved" from the word(s) "EARNED" and "paid for".





Back to top
ShortyRob
LSU Fan
Savannah, GA
Member since Oct 2008
25367 posts

re: Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?


quote:

Liberals have a problem distinguishing the word "deserved" from the word(s) "EARNED" and "paid for".
Liberals barely even understand what the word "earned" even means. Far as they're concerned, people who've "earned" stuff have largely been the beneficiaries of "luck".






Back to top
tigeraddict
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Mar 2007
4590 posts

re: Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?


quote:

Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?


If they paid in to the system then they should get money back out.

This was set up as a forced retirement system. To not get you little money back out, then it becomes another wealth distribution tax....






Back to top
SlowFlowPro
Stanford Fan
Simple Solutions to Complex Probs
Member since Jan 2004
286773 posts
 Online 

re: Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?


quote:

To not get you little money back out, then it becomes another wealth distribution tax....

it is a wealth distribution tax and what you put in is irrelevant for the most part

want an example? think about what happens when a 45 year old who has contributed for 28 years dies as a single person with no kids. who gets his contributions?






Back to top
dante
LSU Fan
Kingwood, TX
Member since Mar 2006
6616 posts

re: Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?


If SS was originally set up by a private citizen he would be in jail for ponsi/pyramid scheme. SS is already means tested. My mother turned 65 last and has worked ALL her life and her check is only slightly more than her sister's, who was a stay at home mom/wife for most of her life. SS is the biggest form of wealth redistribution ever created.





Back to top
Newbomb Turk
Navy Fan
perfectanschlagen
Member since May 2008
9961 posts

re: Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?


quote:

who was a stay at home mom/wife for most of her life. SS is the biggest form of wealth redistribution ever created.


ONLY because when it was set up, woman staying at home was the norm and they were then given (and still do get) the benefit of their husband's contribution.

THIS is one of the big reasons for the gay marriage proponents -- yet another drain on the social security system.



This post was edited on 2/8 at 8:40 am


Back to top
CITWTT
LSU Fan
baton rouge
Member since Sep 2005
31299 posts

re: Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?


Did the govt. take money out of his earned income to pay for the program over his lifes work? Does the SS laws excuse from paying into the system as he was making too much money during that span of time? If he isn't eligible then you have stolen money from him and his family for years under the umbrella of the govt.





Back to top
dante
LSU Fan
Kingwood, TX
Member since Mar 2006
6616 posts

re: Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?


I will give another personal example. My ex-wife's father died at the age of 20 when she was 2 years old. Her mother re-married a year or 2 later, but my ex-wife received SS benefits for 16 years because the step father did not adopt her. It is very safe to say she received more in benefits than her father paid into the system.





Back to top
BugAC
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Oct 2007
17980 posts

re: Why does someone worth 20 million deserve SS at all?


quote:

Mr. Smith, a wealthy retired businessman worth millions, has no business receiving social security funds.


Well then he should not pay into it.

Why don't you want people to receive back the money they pay into something?

Social Security was supposed to be a guarantee against financial hardships, when the stock market was unstable. Now, SS is a guarantee that you will never see that money you put in, if you are 45 or younger.

The problem isn't "rich people" receiving SS. The problem is government laundering money through SS. Scrap it all together.
Completely phase out SS. I will be willing to sacrifice all i've paid into the program, if i could stop paying in tomorrow.

ETA: Not directed at you, Hail. Noticed you are posting NY times comments.



This post was edited on 2/8 at 9:02 am


Back to top



Back to top