re: Official Season 12 American Idol Discussion Thread

Watching now. I must have heard a different song when Janelle sang. I was bored. She was good, but not special for me. NM calling her the best vocal of the night was ridiculous. Well, I guess she was close to the best by that point, but she's not even close to Kree or Angie. I saw them out if order.

Kree needs to get some fashion advice and feel the songs more. She's got the pipes.

Angie was superb.

I liked LA girl.
Teena was good, but she's been better. I'd like to see her stay even though NM is obsessed with her boobs. NM drives me completely bonkers.

Wait, Amber got a 4 person standing O? I didn't think she gave a standing o performance. I thought she did a great job with that song, but I wouldn't have stood. She hit the notes great, but the voice was a little small for it compared to Whitney's. still, she pulled it off. I like her her.

Alaska girl is cute and is better than she was tonight, but the judges slayed her.

Candace was terrific. Loved the voice, the vibe, the song. Enjoyed her more than Angie's or Kree's. that surprised me. Sing choice probably has something to with it.

Candace
Angie
Kree
Teena
LA girl Brianna

Don't know after that. Amber # 6. They need to keep more than 5 girls.

I didn't realize they cut to 5 this week.