Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7 - Page 4 - TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
theunknownknight
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2005
25823 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


quote:

Who gives a shite about some 1950s players. We are discussing these days. Josh Reed is the best I've seen. He was unstoppable, but Tyrann is up there also.


Read the thread. We are talking about the entire history of LSU football. The lack of comprehension these days is destroying our discourse.






Back to top
PurpleAndGold86
LSU Fan
Houston, TX
Member since Jun 2012
8796 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


quote:

Read the thread. TM's 2010 season was not GREAT relative to all of LSU history.


I did read the thread thanks. You are still incorrect. We are talking about players' careers. We are not discussing one individual season in the history of LSU football. Didn't he pass everyone on the list of all time forced fumbles at LSU?? Well some of those came his freshman season. His career at LSU was two seasons and he did some remarkable things in each of those years.

If you would like to discuss the greatest individual season in LSU history, then no, 2010 would not even be in the discussion. But we are discussing the best play makers in their LSU careers, so not counting his 2010 season is just dumb and doesn't make any sense.






Back to top
theunknownknight
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2005
25823 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


quote:

If you would like to discuss the greatest individual season in LSU history, then no, 2010 would not even be in the discussion. But we are discussing the best play makers in their LSU careers, so not counting his 2010 season is just dumb and doesn't make any sense.


AND 2011 >>>>>> 2010. So 2010 didn't add much to his "BEST EVVAAAR!!!!!1" résumé.






Back to top
theunknownknight
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2005
25823 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


I'll say it again, TM was a great playmaker BECAUSE Claiborne being on the field allowed TM the luxury to freely hawk the ball, just like Simon was able to do when he stepped in for TM last year. Claiborne > TM as a player.





Back to top
PurpleAndGold86
LSU Fan
Houston, TX
Member since Jun 2012
8796 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


quote:

AND 2011 >>>>>> 2010. So 2010 didn't add much to his "BEST EVVAAAR!!!!!1" résumé.


Funny. You are trying to bash everyone's comprehension skills and yours are failing miserably here.

Yes 2011 was a better individual season for Tyrann Mathieu than 2010. He did more as a playmaker in 2011 than he did in 2010. Are you just going to throw away the season with the least amount of plays for every person we are discussing here? How many of Mathieu's sacks, fumbles, and picks came as a freshman? So you can't just discount those plays out of the equation just because there were more electric plays made in 2011 than there were in 2010.

What the frick is so hard for you to understand about that?






Back to top
Penrod
LSU Fan
Member since Jan 2011
3365 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


quote:

I can't really say that I have seen an LSU player since the 60s that made so many eye-popping plays as TM-7.


+1

My thoughts exactly. Maybe Casanova and Cannon come close, but neither reaches TM7 level. In fact, if you considered all of college football, I don't think you could name more than 10 in the last 30 years. You could throw out most of the Heisman winners like Gino Toretta and Vinnie Testeverde. They are jokes compared to TM7.






Back to top
LSU92
LSU Fan
New Orleans
Member since Jan 2008
2004 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


quote:

Maybe Casanova and Cannon come close


Casanova was a three time All-American playing all over the field. TM7 did not even play three seasons at LSU.






Back to top
HoustonTigah
LSU Fan
Clear Lake, TX
Member since Jan 2004
80 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


Billy Cannon





Back to top
nofear67
LSU Fan
Houston
Member since Jan 2006
1125 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


quote:

Really? The guy had ONE great season and you wanna say he's the best in QUANTITY in LSU history?

For a freshman, that season was great as well. YOU FAIL!






Back to top
theunknownknight
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Sep 2005
25823 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


quote:

What the frick is so hard for you to understand about that?


Let me put it in words you can understand: one good/decent season + one outstanding season = great college player.

3 to 4 outstanding seasons = legendary player

Which one was Cannon and Casanova?

Which on was TM?

I rest my case.






Back to top
L..S..U..Fan
LSU Fan
Donaldsonville
Member since Oct 2012
514 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7








Back to top
fjohns1
LSU Fan
Member since Oct 2011
1333 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


quote:

The guy had ONE great season


really dude






Back to top
PurpleAndGold86
LSU Fan
Houston, TX
Member since Jun 2012
8796 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


quote:

Let me put it in words you can understand: one good/decent season + one outstanding season = great college player.

3 to 4 outstanding seasons = legendary player

Which one was Cannon and Casanova?

Which on was TM?

I rest my case.


You really can't comprehend anything can you? I said about 3 posts ago I DO NOT THINK AND I AM NOT TRYING TO ARGUE THAT TM7 IS THE GREATEST PLAYMAKER IN LSU HISTORY.

You said he had one great season, which was an idiotic statement. He had 2 great season and the discussion being had is about great playmakers in LSU history.

I'm not saying I think or don't think that Mathieu is as "legendary as Cannon and Casanova", I simply said you are wrong in saying that Mathieu had one great season. Several other posters have agreed with me in saying that as well.







Back to top
flip82lsu
LSU Fan
BATON ROUGE
Member since Oct 2009
3005 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


Jacob Hester





Back to top
Keltic Tiger
LSU Fan
Baton Rouge
Member since Dec 2006
3938 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


"1950's players". Why am I not surprised at the lack of knowledge of LSU football history by the same ranters who think CLM is a horrible coach. Their attention spans are good for at best 4 yrs or so. Watching Casanova run those 3 punts back for TD's against O.Miss, at a time when the rivalry was still red hot, was just as exciting as any of the great plays TM7 did, and I love the way TM7 played. There is a good reason why his name, and Cannon's, name is on the wall at TS. And a good reason why TM7's never will be.





Back to top
lsusportsman2
LSU Fan
Member since Oct 2007
14098 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


Um Billy Cannon? LSU's only Heisman winner? I think there's your answer.





Back to top
charate
LSU Fan
New Orleans
Member since Feb 2012
195 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


Wow. this thread = fail.

TM7 was a very good playmaker, but does that mean we forget he wasnt close to the best corner on his own team. Mo is pissed at you






Back to top
pabgolf
LSU Fan
baton rouge
Member since Dec 2009
1169 posts

re: Name me a better all time play maker in LSU's history than TM7


Charles Alexander





Back to top



Back to top