Do you think Superbad is better than American Pie?????

Superbad was better than American Pie. The dialogue was much funnier and no one had to frick a pastry for cheap laughs.

Superbad is just a funnier movie although I do have a lot of nostalgia for American Pie.

Superbad is a funnier movie

Amercan Pie is a better movie.

AP captured HS more realistically than any other movie ive seen for the most part (not including Dazed and Confused because it was a different era) and had better character development and plot. I love superbad though dont get me wrong

Superbad is the better comedy, American Pie is the better movie overall though

quote:

---

Superbad was just another movie whereas American Pie raised the bar.

---

I'm an old man who was in college when Animal House came out so neither is my generation's movie.

In my mind American Pie is easily the better story but Superbad, partially because of the low brow humor, is more watchable.

American Pie is really good and I liked it very much but I have no desire to re-watch it.

Superbad is one of those movies like Animal House, Blazing Saddles, Vacation, Caddyshack, Trading Places maybe even Porky's that will always be funny.

You could have made the same movie in the 70's, 80's or 90's and it would have been just as funny.

quote:

---

the characters, the stories surrounding each character

---

Also one was about the popular, successful kids and the other was about two unknown everyman type guys.

American Pie was more my time than Superbad and I would still rather watch Superbad

Can't Hardly Wait beats them all though

I never liked American Pie, other than Shannon Elizabeth's parts. I thought Superbad was funny.