re: What physical flaw on a woman makes an otherwise beautiful woman undesirable?

I dated a girl who was gorgeous in just about every way but her thumbs. Not sure what it’s called but I think it’s called Hammer Thumbs. They were like cut off thumbs. Really unattractive.

She was so pretty and had a very well put together body. Her personality was fun and she had a nice family. We dated for months.
I didn’t know that I was repulsed by the look initially but the more I saw them, the more I repelled.

I just could not get past it and had to break up with her.

The wierd thing is that despite my objection to the thumbs, she wasn’t the least bit self conscious about them. That amazes me to this day.