Started By
Message

re: Trey's guitar tone > Barber's guitar tone

Posted on 12/22/14 at 4:09 pm to
Posted by CaptainPanic
18.44311,-64.764021
Member since Sep 2011
25582 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 4:09 pm to
quote:

this thread wasn't creative enough to merit a response
Posted by danman6336
Member since Jan 2005
19440 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 4:25 pm to
My thoughts exactly Captain

Well I haven't seen a well thought out rebuttal to my OP so I now assume I dropped some truth on this board and will move along

Trey > Barber

Ah yeah
Posted by Spaulding Smails
Milano’s Bar
Member since Jun 2012
18805 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 4:27 pm to
take the challenge...Barber v. Trey NYE

I'm not afraid, are you?
Posted by danman6336
Member since Jan 2005
19440 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 4:47 pm to
sure why not

but it's a pretty subjective thing, and what's to stop the tDB brahs from saying lolfishsux about everything without having even listened to it

I get the feeling that's the case most of the time with the anti-Phish sentiment on this board anyway
Posted by CaptainPanic
18.44311,-64.764021
Member since Sep 2011
25582 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 4:49 pm to
quote:

I get the feeling that's the case most of the time with the anti-everything sentiment on this board anyway
FIFY
This post was edited on 12/22/14 at 4:50 pm
Posted by Spaulding Smails
Milano’s Bar
Member since Jun 2012
18805 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 4:51 pm to
We'll get someone unbiased to either side and have them give it a critical analysis, and eventual decide a winner.

They will have to be completely on the fence, with zero hatred towards tDB and Phish.

We obviously aren't going to get Burt, Andre, Heady, you or myself to judge this
Posted by danman6336
Member since Jan 2005
19440 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 4:54 pm to
I could judge it pretty well

I feel like I'm one of the few on here that legitimately likes both bands. Me and Andre.

BV and Burt just straight up don't like Phish. Not too sure about you either Spauld.

Capt and heady are too far on the Phish side. Andre seems to genuinely like both of them.

Whatever, we'll figure it out. I've just decided if I'm picking sides give me Phish all day everyday.
Posted by HeadyBrosevelt
the Verde River
Member since Jan 2013
21590 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 4:57 pm to
Sticky is probably the smartest expert on here so he should do it.
Posted by Spaulding Smails
Milano’s Bar
Member since Jun 2012
18805 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 4:58 pm to
I've been talking to the Bisco Godfather and him and I are coming up with a scoring sheet.

One thing is for sure, minus points for Mirrors or Farmhouse
Posted by link
Member since Feb 2009
19867 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 4:58 pm to
quote:

12.31.95 Chalk Dust Torture
never heard this song before 2 minutes ago, but if 3:00 to 6:22 was completely improvised, that was impressive. of course, outside of that 3 and a half minutes, lol.

can a barber fan post a rebuttal jam for comparison?
Posted by danman6336
Member since Jan 2005
19440 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 5:02 pm to
quote:

One thing is for sure, minus points for Mirrors or Farmhouse
I'm not sure tDB can get into the subtracting point for bad songwriting contest

Not a fight they would win
Posted by CaptainPanic
18.44311,-64.764021
Member since Sep 2011
25582 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 5:02 pm to
All usual MB antics aside, this argument is pretty stupid. Regardless of the outcome, however that will even be judged, it will still be labeled unfair or biased. There isn't a way to solve this "problem" unless there is a vote from a legitimate pool. which there isn't.

As far as boosting the argument, only one poster posted links to support their case and that was only from one year of playing. Needs more ground rules imo
Posted by Spaulding Smails
Milano’s Bar
Member since Jun 2012
18805 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 5:04 pm to
I'm at work, I don't have youtube to shine the spotlight on Barber, but I can say 09 is obviously a good year to start at
Posted by HeadyBrosevelt
the Verde River
Member since Jan 2013
21590 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 5:06 pm to
quote:

never heard this song before 2 minutes ago, but if 3:00 to 6:22 was completely improvised, that was impressive.


It's fappening
Posted by CaptainPanic
18.44311,-64.764021
Member since Sep 2011
25582 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 5:06 pm to
quote:

3:00 to 6:22
Posted by danman6336
Member since Jan 2005
19440 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 5:09 pm to
11/27/98 Weekapaug Groove

from about 2:13 to whenever Trey is pretty much killing it
Posted by Dave England
Member since Apr 2013
5107 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 5:16 pm to
Posted by HeadyBrosevelt
the Verde River
Member since Jan 2013
21590 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 5:17 pm to
Posted by danman6336
Member since Jan 2005
19440 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 5:18 pm to
9/14/99 Down With Disease

start video at about 44:45
Posted by Spaulding Smails
Milano’s Bar
Member since Jun 2012
18805 posts
Posted on 12/22/14 at 5:18 pm to
Start here, more to come after work
LINK
first pageprev pagePage 4 of 7Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram