Hall of fame worthy or not

Posted by Statsattack
Are these players and coachs hall of fame worthy please feel free to add
Edgerin James - no
Tony Dungy - no
Julius Peppers - yes
Dick Vermiel - yes
Charles Haley - yes
Dan Reeves - yes
Issac Bruce - no
Tory Holt - no
Ronde Barber - no
Simeon Rice - no
Jimmy Johnson - yes
Brian Urlacher - yes
Tom Coughlin - yes
Kevin Greene - no
Donovan Mcnabb - yes
Please add just naming people at top of my head

Mario Williams
Tony Bosselli
Steve Mcnair

James, Vermiel, Haley, Johnson, Urlacher, Greene I agree with.

quote:

---

Solid WR for a while. Just don't see him as hof worthy.

---

fair enough

Mario Williams - no, has 7 more career sacks than Will Smith
Tony Bosselli - no
Steve Mcnair - strong no just to avoid the super uncomfortable induction

Edgerin James - Like him, but no
Tony Dungy - yes
Julius Peppers - no
Dick Vermiel - eventually
Charles Haley - would think so, eventually
Dan Reeves - yes
Issac Bruce -yes
Tory Holt - no
Ronde Barber - eventually
Simeon Rice - no
Jimmy Johnson - easily
Brian Urlacher - yes
Tom Coughlin - si
Kevin Greene - wwf hall of fame maybe
Donovan Mcnabb - chunkys soup hall of..eventually

Urlacher is the only one on your list who I would confidently say deserves to be in.

Haley may get in because he's the only player in history with Five Super Bowl rings, that's obviously a team thing so its more "noteworthy" induction than "he was legitimately that good" induction.

The others are all Hall of Very Good, IMO.

EDIT: The above is just players. Jimmy and Dungy will be in.

Vince Wilfork - I think so but not sure who agrees
Terell Owens -
Willie Mcginist -
Marvin Harrison -
Andre Johnson -

I think Eli is borderline right now. What stands out is Super Bowl wins but you wouldn't put him in the same category as someone like Marino despite the latters lack of rings.

quote:

---

The others are all Hall of Very Good, IMO.

---

Isaac Bruce was 2nd behind Jerry Rice in receiving yardage when he retired. He gets in.