- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
BBWAA Awards (MVP, Cy Young, ROY, MOY) Debate Thread
Posted on 10/1/13 at 1:40 pm
Posted on 10/1/13 at 1:40 pm
How would y'all fill out ballots?
NL MVP
1. A. McCutchen, PIT
2. M. Carpenter, STL
3. P. Goldschmidt, ARZ
4. S. Choo, CIN
5. J. Votto, CIN
6. C. Kershaw, LAD
7. C. Gomez, MIL
8. Y. Molina, STL
9. A. Simmons, ATL
10. F. Freeman, ATL
AL MVP
1. M. Trout, LAA
2. M. Cabrera, DET
3. J. Donaldson, OAK
4. C. Davis, BAL
5. E. Longoria, TB
6. R. Cano, NYY
7. D. Pedroia, BOS
8. B. Zobrist, TB
9. A. Beltre, TEX
10. J. Ellsbury, BOS
NL Cy Young
1. C. Kershaw, LAD
2. A. Wainwright, STL
3. C. Lee, PHI
4. M. Harvey, NYM
5. J. Fernandez, MIA
AL Cy Young
1. M. Scherzer, DET
2. Y. Darvish, TEX
3. C. Sale, CWS
4. F. Hernandez, SEA
5. A. Sanchez, DET
NL Rookie of the Year
1. J. Fernandez, MIA
2. Y. Puig, LAD
3. J. Teheran, ATL
AL Rookie of the Year
1. W. Myers, TB
2. J. Iglesias, BOS/DET
3. D. Straily, OAK
NL Manager of the Year
1. C. Hurdle, PIT
2. D. Mattingly, LAD
3. F. Gonzalez, ATL
AL Manager of the Year
1. T. Francona, CLE
2. J. Girardi, NYY
3. J. Maddon, TB
Fire away
NL MVP
1. A. McCutchen, PIT
2. M. Carpenter, STL
3. P. Goldschmidt, ARZ
4. S. Choo, CIN
5. J. Votto, CIN
6. C. Kershaw, LAD
7. C. Gomez, MIL
8. Y. Molina, STL
9. A. Simmons, ATL
10. F. Freeman, ATL
AL MVP
1. M. Trout, LAA
2. M. Cabrera, DET
3. J. Donaldson, OAK
4. C. Davis, BAL
5. E. Longoria, TB
6. R. Cano, NYY
7. D. Pedroia, BOS
8. B. Zobrist, TB
9. A. Beltre, TEX
10. J. Ellsbury, BOS
NL Cy Young
1. C. Kershaw, LAD
2. A. Wainwright, STL
3. C. Lee, PHI
4. M. Harvey, NYM
5. J. Fernandez, MIA
AL Cy Young
1. M. Scherzer, DET
2. Y. Darvish, TEX
3. C. Sale, CWS
4. F. Hernandez, SEA
5. A. Sanchez, DET
NL Rookie of the Year
1. J. Fernandez, MIA
2. Y. Puig, LAD
3. J. Teheran, ATL
AL Rookie of the Year
1. W. Myers, TB
2. J. Iglesias, BOS/DET
3. D. Straily, OAK
NL Manager of the Year
1. C. Hurdle, PIT
2. D. Mattingly, LAD
3. F. Gonzalez, ATL
AL Manager of the Year
1. T. Francona, CLE
2. J. Girardi, NYY
3. J. Maddon, TB
Fire away
10
Posted on 10/1/13 at 1:42 pm to The White Lobster
i have the same winners for every award
Posted on 10/1/13 at 1:43 pm to The White Lobster
Agree except I say Miggy over Trout
Posted on 10/1/13 at 1:45 pm to The White Lobster
2013 NL BABIPOY
Chris Johnson
Chris Johnson
Posted on 10/1/13 at 1:46 pm to LSUsmartass
I was really rooting for .400
Posted on 10/1/13 at 1:47 pm to The White Lobster
i would definitely have greinke on my cy young ballot, but it's not like it matters that much
Posted on 10/1/13 at 1:47 pm to The White Lobster
Pretty clear cut winners this year IMO...
NL MVP
1. A. McCutchen, PIT
2. M. Carpenter, STL
3. P. Goldschmidt, ARZ
4. S. Choo, CIN
5. J. Votto, CIN
6. C. Kershaw, LAD
7. C. Gomez, MIL
8. Y. Molina, STL
9. A. Simmons, ATL
10. F. Freeman, ATL
AL MVP
1. M. Trout, LAA
2. M. Cabrera, DET
3. J. Donaldson, OAK
4. C. Davis, BAL
5. E. Longoria, TB
6. R. Cano, NYY
7. D. Pedroia, BOS
8. B. Zobrist, TB
9. A. Beltre, TEX
10. J. Ellsbury, BOS
NL Cy Young
1. C. Kershaw, LAD
2. A. Wainwright, STL
3. C. Lee, PHI
4. M. Harvey, NYM
5. J. Fernandez, MIA
AL Cy Young
1. M. Scherzer, DET
2. Y. Darvish, TEX
3. C. Sale, CWS
4. F. Hernandez, SEA
5. A. Sanchez, DET
NL Rookie of the Year
1. J. Fernandez, MIA
2. Y. Puig, LAD
3. J. Teheran, ATL
AL Rookie of the Year
1. W. Myers, TB
2. J. Iglesias, BOS/DET
3. D. Straily, OAK
NL Manager of the Year
1. C. Hurdle, PIT
2. D. Mattingly, LAD
3. F. Gonzalez, ATL
AL Manager of the Year
1. T. Francona, CLE
2. J. Girardi, NYY
3. J. Maddon, TB
NL MVP
1. A. McCutchen, PIT
2. M. Carpenter, STL
3. P. Goldschmidt, ARZ
4. S. Choo, CIN
5. J. Votto, CIN
6. C. Kershaw, LAD
7. C. Gomez, MIL
8. Y. Molina, STL
9. A. Simmons, ATL
10. F. Freeman, ATL
AL MVP
1. M. Trout, LAA
2. M. Cabrera, DET
3. J. Donaldson, OAK
4. C. Davis, BAL
5. E. Longoria, TB
6. R. Cano, NYY
7. D. Pedroia, BOS
8. B. Zobrist, TB
9. A. Beltre, TEX
10. J. Ellsbury, BOS
NL Cy Young
1. C. Kershaw, LAD
2. A. Wainwright, STL
3. C. Lee, PHI
4. M. Harvey, NYM
5. J. Fernandez, MIA
AL Cy Young
1. M. Scherzer, DET
2. Y. Darvish, TEX
3. C. Sale, CWS
4. F. Hernandez, SEA
5. A. Sanchez, DET
NL Rookie of the Year
1. J. Fernandez, MIA
2. Y. Puig, LAD
3. J. Teheran, ATL
AL Rookie of the Year
1. W. Myers, TB
2. J. Iglesias, BOS/DET
3. D. Straily, OAK
NL Manager of the Year
1. C. Hurdle, PIT
2. D. Mattingly, LAD
3. F. Gonzalez, ATL
AL Manager of the Year
1. T. Francona, CLE
2. J. Girardi, NYY
3. J. Maddon, TB
Posted on 10/1/13 at 1:48 pm to rockchlkjayhku11
would also have hyun jin ryu on my NL rookie ballot
Posted on 10/1/13 at 1:48 pm to The White Lobster
At least you don't have to eat hats
Posted on 10/1/13 at 1:53 pm to The White Lobster
quote:
Fire away
You made a good list.
The NL MVP is a toss up. I would tend to lean McCutchen but there is a list of 4-5 guys after that are very deserving and would not be shocked if any one of them win the award.
NL Cy Young is Kershaw.
NL Rookie Fernandez.
NL Manager is Hurdle by default. He really isnt a good manager but will win because of the Pirates post season entry. None of the other managers (Matheny,Gonzalez or Mattingly) stand out from one another all that much.
AL MVP will be Miggy. (Playoffs to Trouts no playoffs will kill him with traditionalist voters.)
AL Cy Young Sherzer
AL Rookie Will Myers.
AL Manager is Francona, no question.
Posted on 10/1/13 at 1:53 pm to The White Lobster
quote:
NL MVP
1. A. McCutchen, PIT
AL MVP
1. M. Trout, LAA
NL Cy Young
1. C. Kershaw, LAD
AL Cy Young
1. M. Scherzer, DET
NL Rookie of the Year
1. J. Fernandez, MIA (but will prolly be puig)
AL Rookie of the Year
1. W. Myers, TB
2. J. Iglesias, BOS/DET (could see this going either way)
NL Manager of the Year
1. C. Hurdle, PIT
AL Manager of the Year
1. T. Francona, CLE
Both of these will be landslides
Posted on 10/1/13 at 1:55 pm to Nick Papa Georgio
Darvish, Sale, Felix, and Scherzer are all really close IMO. I probably should have had Felix higher
Posted on 10/1/13 at 1:59 pm to WestCoastAg
Ryu, Shelby, and Teheran are all basically the same. Ryu might have had the best season, but it's hard for me to call him a rookie.
Posted on 10/1/13 at 2:01 pm to The White Lobster
quote:
Darvish, Sale, Felix, and Scherzer are all really close IMO.
They are. The two main races that are really toss ups between 3-5 people in my mind are the NL MVP and the AL Cy Young. The rookie of the year awards are as well to but to a lesser extent.
Posted on 10/1/13 at 2:02 pm to The White Lobster
I don't see how people can give MVP's to players on awful teams.
Posted on 10/1/13 at 2:05 pm to The White Lobster
i can dig it
Posted on 10/1/13 at 2:17 pm to Sevendust912
How is it their fault that their teams suck?
Posted on 10/1/13 at 2:19 pm to The White Lobster
quote:
How is it their fault that their teams suck?
Well, you can make this argument all you want but it does matter in how the actual voters decide.
Posted on 10/1/13 at 2:20 pm to Sevendust912
quote:
I don't see how people can give MVP's to players on awful teams.
That's why I wish it was MOP instead of MVP. We reward the best of everything else, but the best player only counts if your team was worth a shite.
Posted on 10/1/13 at 2:59 pm to swamie
quote:
I don't see how people can give MVP's to players on awful teams.
it's the media dopes
1 year they claim it doesn't matter, so they can Vote Sosa, then claim it does and vote for Howard, etc. Baseball writers are asshats.
MLB has to change the voting. you have people voting, who don't even cover the sport of baseball anymore and havent for decades, yet still get to vote.
How the frick does Keith Law get a vote?
This post was edited on 10/1/13 at 3:09 pm
Page 1 of 3
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News