TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST | Page 3 | TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
Lester Earl
LSU Fan
#buganation
Member since Nov 2003
187688 posts
 Online 

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


Shouldn't matter. There isn't a roster spot designated for a team offense.

The individual player gets the touchdown in every other fashion. If you just so happen to have that player, you should get the points.






Back to top
swamie
Memphis Fan
Where opportunity meets hard work
Member since Jan 2007
22682 posts

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


quote:

The individual player gets the touchdown in every other fashion


Because those touchdowns happen on offense. Does a kicker get credit for a 2 pt conversion?

How about in baseball when my pitcher hits a HR. does he get credit? Nope, he's out with the defensive unit.

If you want to create scoring for different units, lets ask RTSports for a team offense spot. I want to double up on Rodgers and the Packers offense.






Back to top
MrWiseGuy
USA Fan
Member since Dec 2009
14154 posts
 Online 

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


Should be put to a vote.

People's stances on this issue aren't going to change. Just have a vote to decide if more people prefer it the old way or the new way.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Lester Earl
LSU Fan
#buganation
Member since Nov 2003
187688 posts
 Online 

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


quote:

Because those touchdowns happen on offense. Does a kicker get credit for a 2 pt conversion?


Why should he? If he's not kicking then he shouldn't get points.

Re: the pitcher doesn't get a hr because he's not in your offensive lineup. He's designated as a pitcher.

A football guy being in your lineup is universal. If he makes a TD you need to be rewarded.

That's like saying a RB shouldn't get credit for a TD pass if he throws one....."We'll he's not a QB!!!!!! "






Back to top
TigerPhan27
Tulane Fan
edgy racial f'n pervert.
Member since Apr 2008
15693 posts

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


quote:

If you want to create scoring for different units, lets ask RTSports for a team offense spot. I want to double up on Rodgers and the Packers offense.


agreed. you shouldnt be able to have the same player in your lineup twice. i.e. WR and DT/ST






Back to top
Lester Earl
LSU Fan
#buganation
Member since Nov 2003
187688 posts
 Online 

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


QB and WR share TDs all the time





Back to top
Lester Earl
LSU Fan
#buganation
Member since Nov 2003
187688 posts
 Online 

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


And if that's the case, take the TD away from the unit and give it to the indidual player





Back to top
geauxlsu07
Louisville Fan
Queens, NY via Alexandria
Member since Jan 2005
34775 posts

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


anyway we can add a spot for just a return man?





Back to top
  Replies (0)
TigerPhan27
Tulane Fan
edgy racial f'n pervert.
Member since Apr 2008
15693 posts

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


quote:

QB and WR share TDs all the time


they aren't the same player






Back to top
TigerPhan27
Tulane Fan
edgy racial f'n pervert.
Member since Apr 2008
15693 posts

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


quote:

And if that's the case, take the TD away from the unit and give it to the indidual player


that's fine, as long as one player doesn't get credited with the same TD twice






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Lester Earl
LSU Fan
#buganation
Member since Nov 2003
187688 posts
 Online 

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


How is say, Leon Washington the same player as a D/ST?





Back to top
swamie
Memphis Fan
Where opportunity meets hard work
Member since Jan 2007
22682 posts

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


quote:

Why should he? If he's not kicking then he shouldn't get points.


What if he lines up for the kick and takes it in around the corner?

quote:

Re: the pitcher doesn't get a hr because he's not in your offensive lineup. He's designated as a pitcher.


Baseball isn't a great example, but neither is this. Harvin isn't designated in fanatsy as WR/PR or WR/DST, just WR. I don't think WR is universal. If he makes a TD, you're rewarded for drafting or picking up the unit he made the TD on.


MWG, I'm sure we'll have a vote. I thought we did last year and the vote was 8-6.






Back to top
TigerPhan27
Tulane Fan
edgy racial f'n pervert.
Member since Apr 2008
15693 posts

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


quote:

How is say, Leon Washington the same player as a D/ST?


are you starting leon washinton in your lineup and his st team unit?






Back to top
swamie
Memphis Fan
Where opportunity meets hard work
Member since Jan 2007
22682 posts

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


quote:

And if that's the case, take the TD away from the unit and give it to the indidual player


That's better than double dipping, but you're taking value from an entire unit to up the value of a few weapons.






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Lester Earl
LSU Fan
#buganation
Member since Nov 2003
187688 posts
 Online 

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


quote:

What if he lines up for the kick and takes it in around the corner?


It's not in the scoring to allow that. If it was I'd be all for it


A RB isn't designated as a QB but he still gets points for a TD pass. He's not designated as a WR yet can catch TD passes. A WR and QB can run TDs in, but they aren't RBs






Back to top
Lester Earl
LSU Fan
#buganation
Member since Nov 2003
187688 posts
 Online 

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


quote:

are you starting leon washinton in your lineup and his st team unit?


That doesn't make them the same

Defensive scoring is so forced anyway. Both should get points but if only 1 is, it should be the player






Back to top
swamie
Memphis Fan
Where opportunity meets hard work
Member since Jan 2007
22682 posts

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


quote:

A RB isn't designated as a QB but he still gets points for a TD pass. He's not designated as a WR yet can catch TD passes. A WR and QB can run TDs in, but they aren't RBs


All part of the same unit and none of those positions would yield two TD for one player.

And I'm not for diluting the value of a unit to do so if we only awarded points to the player.







Back to top
  Replies (0)
TigerPhan27
Tulane Fan
edgy racial f'n pervert.
Member since Apr 2008
15693 posts

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


quote:

A RB isn't designated as a QB but he still gets points for a TD pass. He's not designated as a WR yet can catch TD passes. A WR and QB can run TDs in, but they aren't RBs


the RB is not throwing the TD to himself and scoring two TD's on the same play






Back to top
TigerPhan27
Tulane Fan
edgy racial f'n pervert.
Member since Apr 2008
15693 posts

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


quote:

Defensive scoring is so forced anyway. Both should get points but if only 1 is, it should be the player


I would say eliminate ST scoring from the DT/ST position and limit it to defense only.

I would also love to eliminate kickers. ir did we do that already?






Back to top
  Replies (0)
Lester Earl
LSU Fan
#buganation
Member since Nov 2003
187688 posts
 Online 

re: TDFL - Tiger Conference TONIGHT 8:00 PM CST


But they share a TD the same way a D and player would on a Defebsive or ST touchdown

It's more of an assist than a share






Back to top


Back to top