Top 5 Saints Players of All Time

Drew Brees
Archie Manning
Willie Roaf
Rickey Jackson
Pat Swilling

quote:

---

Chad, how could you not have Deuce in the Top 5? Saints' all-time leading rusher and consistently made plays, one of the most beloved Saints of all time.

---

dude, you left off rickey jackson. don't speak.

Rickey Jackson was great, yes, but I think an argument can be made for my guys to be in the top 5. And it's hard to separate one of the Dome Patrol from the rest. I think as a unit they were awesome, to me, it would be hard to say that Rickey Jackson stood out over Vaughan Johnson, Pat Swilling, and Sam Mills because they played so well as a unit, it's hard to pick one out of those four because they were all tremendous players for the Saints. So maybe I should have put Dome Patrol as one of my 5 then?

But you still didn't answer my question as to why you don't think Deuce is a Top 5 in your book?

quote:

---

But you still didn't answer my question as to why you don't think Deuce is a Top 5 in your book?

---

dude barely has 6000 yards rushing over a 7 year career. Only had 2 years worth talking about. Only 2 probowls, less than any player I named. Zero all pro's. You have zero argument for deuce over any of my players.

quote:

---

Rickey Jackson was great, yes, but I think an argument can be made for my guys to be in the top 5

---

The argument would be stupid though.

quote:

---

it would be hard to say that Rickey Jackson stood out over Vaughan Johnson, Pat Swilling, and Sam Mills

---

Except that he did stand out

1. Drew Brees
2. Ricky Jackson
3. Willie Roaf
4. Deuce McAllister
5. LaRoi Glover

1. Drew Brees
2. Deuce McAllister
3. Archie Manning
4. Joe Horn
5. Willie Roaf

Good list



1. Drew Brees
2. Rickey Jackson
3. Archie Manning
4. Willie Roaf
5. Mortan Anderson

I can totally accept swapping deuce for Evans. That's legit.

I understand your point Chad, but you can't bash me for putting Deuce in the Top 5. I think a lot of people would agree Deuce merits a Top 5 spot based on what he accomplished with the Saints as well as in the community. And hey, Deuce played his entire career with the Saints, unlike Brees, Jackson, and Glover. So that counts as well.

quote:

---

I can totally accept swapping deuce for Evans. That's legit.

---

not trying to overly dog deuce but he quite possibly is the most overrated saint ever.