beaver USA Fan The 755 Club Member since Sep 2009 33283 posts
Thoughts on a trade just proposed to me (Posted on 4/19/13 at 4:31 pm)
I'd give up Cargo and Carl Crawford and receive Matt Kemp, Hunter Pence and Ryan Zimmerman
My team right now: C Rosario 1B Goldschmidt 2B Rickie Weeks 3B Frazier SS Rutledge OF Cargo OF Harper OF Crawford UT Parra UT Reynolds BE Bautista (day to day) BE Andrelton Simmons BE Puig DL Cespedes DL Aramis Ramirez DL Eaton
Thoughts? I mean Crawford is going to get hurt before long
papz LSU Fan New Orleans Member since Jul 2008 4157 posts
re: Thoughts on a trade just proposed to me (Posted on 4/19/13 at 4:42 pm to beaver)
If you didn't have Ramirez on the DL, I'd probably take it. But since you do, I'd stand pat. He should be back before long. Pretty even regardless... I don't think you go wrong with either. If you wanted to load up on 3rd baseman though, they make great trade bait.
re: Thoughts on a trade just proposed to me (Posted on 4/19/13 at 5:19 pm to beaver)
I would take it. This trade also really depends on your valuation of Crawford. Kemp and Cargo are close enough to a wash even though I prefer cargo. Zimmerman is easily the third best player in the deal. Just play Ramirez at utility.
Pragmatic PiG California Fan Fayetteville Member since Nov 2012 282 posts
re: Thoughts on a trade just proposed to me (Posted on 4/20/13 at 1:17 am to beaver)
Normally I'd be inclined to take that deal but I am wondering how healthy kemp and Zimmerman actually are. Zimm's throwing motion looks way out of whack and kemp just looks awful. Both had significant shoulder injuries..........I am highly invested in kemp.....he could contribute mightily to sinking me