re: Should We?: Jamaal Charles

quote:

---

Cadet just knows more receiver routes as opposed to HB routes Ingram knows. But we have better actual receivers that do that.

And Cadet never runs so it isn't like things are disguised. He's a waste of roster space.

---

I'm not a fan of Cadet at all, & you pretty much know that it's going to be a pass when he's in the game. It wouldn't take much to get him off the roster, but imo there isn't a better option for us in obvious passing downs. Cadet runs the best routes of all the RB's and has the best hands of all the RB's imo. Ingram has pretty damn good hands, but Cadet catches the ball like a WR(I realize some people won't like this opinion...but I've only seen him drop the ball twice since he's been with us). Unfortunately, CSP won't replace him until he finds someone that he likes more imo.

While Cadet is a 1 trick pony & couldn't even stiff a roster spot with most teams...Murphy doesn't even contribute to the team besides fumbling a return. As shitty as Cadet is as a returner...I'd rather him than Murphy, b/c he rarely fumbles & doesn't have random brain farts.