Dude is a game manager and nothing more.
You sir are not following college football. Last year, I would have agreed. However, this year he has progressed significantly and was a very good passer.
JPW and McElroy were game managers - McCarron is a much better passer than people think. Just watch game film from last years BCS NCG in NOLA as well as this year.
Am I saying he's the next Joe Montana or Tom Brady, no. But to say he's a game manager and nothing more shows me you know dick about football.