Is Richard Murphy worthy of starting?

shite

quote:

---

To me he is a 3rd down back at best.

---

Thanks for the stellar insight. You sure it doesn't say "LSU" on your check?

i ra'd

I'd ask you to explain your reasoning, but you might as well quit while you're ahead.

honestly..what has either of the 3 backs did to seperate themselves from one another, none of them have done much of anything in a game so before asking is murphy worthy of starting ask yourself if either one is

He deserves it. He's earned it and I'm happy for the guy. We can't give him 25 carries a game. He can't handle it. I'm glad he's the listed starter though

What I don't understand is how people who have not been to 1 single minute of practice can say who they think "deserves" to start at any position whether it be RB DB or punter. Until the season starts it's pure speculation for the most part for 99.9% of the fan base. I, for one, dont give a hoot in hell how Imany stars a freshman had in H.S. If he isn't mentally ready to start then he should wait his turn no matter how badly I want to see him play.

I trust Wilson and gonzo thus far. If they think he is #1, I'm with them. Like I said, he can't physically handle 25 carries a game. That leaves room for someone to prove they deserve carries.