2005: Tasmin Mitchell
Wasn't he supposed to be "Lebron" like in high school? What happened? I heard about him in 8th grade as the next big thing and was merely an above average role player in college.
I actually got into a rather nasty email argument with Randy Rosetta (I think) about him. Big story in the Advocate when he graduated (something about him being an alltime great in the history of the program), I sent an email saying I felt the kid was a nice guy but a fairly mediocre baller. The sportwriter basically had an embolism about my comment that he wasn't a top 10 at his position here, much less in the top 10 overall; his responses were rude as shite and not very convincing either.