Standard scoring. Who would you rather ROS? I have the opportunity to trade Hill and Goff (other guy has 2 QBs on bye week 6) for Thomas and probably a trash piece like Maclin.

Currently the scoring for the 2 is practically identical fwiw

4 ...

Report Post

Posted by wildtigercat93

Member since Jul 2011

112312 posts

Posted on 10/5/17 at 12:49 pm to CoachKlein

Thomas

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by Cajunsaints

Member since Aug 2014

690 posts

Posted on 10/5/17 at 12:58 pm to CoachKlein

How is this even a question. Thomas all day

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by jojothetireguy

Live out in Coconut Grove

Member since Jan 2009

10484 posts

Posted on 10/5/17 at 2:52 pm to CoachKlein

In standard scoring, i don't think it's as clear as some think. Hill is always a threat for a TD on a single play. He could easily score 12 points with one catch. Thomas's downfield big play ability is limited due to the routes he runs and the fact that the Saints love to spread the ball round. Remember Snead is coming back which could limit his targets even more.

Thomas is averaging 12.4 with his long being 33
Hill is averaging 13.7 with a long of 75

Now i'm not saying i wouldn't rather Thomas, just saying i think it's not so clear cut

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by GynoSandberg

Member since Jan 2006

72010 posts

Posted on 10/5/17 at 3:02 pm to jojothetireguy

Hill also has 3 and 4 point games. People let his IRL ability cloud his fantasy outlook. There’s no real in between

Thomas has 80 or a touch (both in 2) in every game besides his matchup w Rhodes, who has graded as best CB thus far

Snead coming back helps Thomas not hurts imo

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by CoachKlein

Ratchet City

Member since Mar 2015

1492 posts

Posted on 10/5/17 at 3:20 pm to GynoSandberg

My gut was and is telling me Thomas, mainly because I think he has a higher floor. Just wanted to be sure I'm not getting too caught up in ADP

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by lsusportsman2