Started By
Message

re: OK so you don't Like "O". Answer the questions logically so I can begin to understand

Posted on 2/13/18 at 12:08 pm to
Posted by rickyh
Positiger Nation
Member since Dec 2003
12464 posts
Posted on 2/13/18 at 12:08 pm to
We traveled to Alabama about 1972 or three and watched The Bear coached Tide beat our Tigers 30 to nothing. No one could beat the Bear back them. Help Mac pack is all we heard. Whining was alive even back then. But we still backed our Tigers. Watching them lose for years under Hallman and a string of other coaches didn't dampen our support. We have watched many losing Tiger teams. Back in the day, an 8 win season would have made most people happy and any bowl was a big thing back then. Beating Wyoming in a bowl one year was a beautiful thing. We weren't spoiled little cry babies that think every year if we don't win the SEC or national championship that we are somehow failures. Back the team. All this negativity hurts our look as fans. This generation has destroyed the true spirit of Tiger stadium. Can't stay past halftime. Sickening.
Posted by Nix to Twillie
Houston, TX
Member since Jan 2015
17838 posts
Posted on 2/13/18 at 12:20 pm to
quote:

Watching them lose for years under Hallman and a string of other coaches didn't dampen our support.


quote:

We weren't spoiled little cry babies that think every year if we don't win the SEC or national championship that we are somehow failures.


All of you old farts assume that everyone currently dissatisfied with the direction of the program never lived to see the years in which LSU struggled, when most of the time you couldn’t be more wrong.

I’m 34 and started going to games in 1990. The Hallman era was when I fell in love with the Tigers. So don’t give me that “you don’t know what it’s like” crap.

I love LSU today just as much as I did then and I’m concerned about the direction of the program. Is that so crazy?

quote:

Back in the day, an 8 win season would have made most people happy and any bowl was a big thing back then.


Well then it’s a good thing we’ve evolved past this. You live in a world now where LSU has won championships—and rather recently. It’s not out of line to expect them to compete for them more than they are. If you want to hang your hat on 8 wins and call it a day that’s fine, but most of us expect more out of LSU. I wish O the best, but as of now I don’t think he’s the one to get us back to the top. And unlike you, I think that’s NOT okay.

quote:

All this negativity hurts our look as fans.


Again, this very thread was made to bait negativity.


This post was edited on 2/13/18 at 12:26 pm
Posted by GeauxTigerTM
Member since Sep 2006
30596 posts
Posted on 2/13/18 at 2:17 pm to
quote:

We traveled to Alabama about 1972 or three and watched The Bear coached Tide beat our Tigers 30 to nothing. No one could beat the Bear back them. Help Mac pack is all we heard. Whining was alive even back then. But we still backed our Tigers. Watching them lose for years under Hallman and a string of other coaches didn't dampen our support. We have watched many losing Tiger teams. Back in the day, an 8 win season would have made most people happy and any bowl was a big thing back then. Beating Wyoming in a bowl one year was a beautiful thing. We weren't spoiled little cry babies that think every year if we don't win the SEC or national championship that we are somehow failures. Back the team. All this negativity hurts our look as fans. This generation has destroyed the true spirit of Tiger stadium. Can't stay past halftime. Sickening.


I'm copying and pasting this post of mine from another thread but since your post is essentially the same drivel my response to his fits well here.

quote:

Start that rant at the spring of 1982 and I'm 12 and I'm right there with you...except I happen to think that what we've done to ourselves with this coaching hire and what he has done thus far and continues to do is sending us back to the days when we all HOPED to be better than what we were. That doesn't mean I did not love being a fan then...loving it when our Tigers jumped into the conversation for a bit...seeing them potentially climb into the Top 15 in my weekly SI magazine, etc. Those were incredible times and being a fan THEN was assuredly different. We were fans for reasons OTHER THAN just winning. and I agree, there are some in our fan base, and most of them are younger which is not their fault at all, whose reasons for being an LSU fan revolve almost entirely on pulling for a winner because it's literally all they've known.

But which do you rather? Pining away hoping to one day reach that elite status we envied in Notre Dame, or Nebraska, or Oklahoma, or Alabama, etc or being in that group ourselves? Everything in our program changed that night of January 4th 2004. It was no longer a dream...we'd made it. I remember standing there in the terrace in tears thinking about how my Dad had died a year before and missed it...thinking of all those games and times we'd talked about one day getting to that point. Of being in the Dome with him years before getting beaten by Nebraska...again.

And do you remember what Saban said when asked shortly after on the sidelines what he was going to do next? I'm paraphrasing but it was essentially, "Start working to do it again next year."

You may disagree...but for most of us that's literally all we're trying to do. Stay here. Getting here was hard. All those years you described, while great in their own ways, were not comparable to ACTUALLY being part of the elite and you know it. So for many of us, even those of us with time frames longer than many of the kids you seem to be describing, the goal is to remain in contention and there are good reasons to be worrying aloud that the moves we've made over the past year are reversing our course back to those days where you needed to search for silver linings in order to find wonderful things to love about the program. Oh...should the day come that we fall back entirely to the pack and we're forced to do that again, I'll do the same and find my silver linings. I'm an LSU fan...it's how I got started with this.

In the meantime, though, I'm going to fight like hell to stop the slide I think we've hopped onto, regardless of how much you r others attempt to pretend the only people sending up warning flares are either children or malcontents. Like you've I've earned the right to voice my concerns over many slim years of being a fan.
This post was edited on 2/13/18 at 2:19 pm
Posted by GeauxTigerTM
Member since Sep 2006
30596 posts
Posted on 2/13/18 at 4:02 pm to
quote:

We traveled to Alabama about 1972 or three and watched The Bear coached Tide beat our Tigers 30 to nothing. No one could beat the Bear back them. Help Mac pack is all we heard. Whining was alive even back then. But we still backed our Tigers. Watching them lose for years under Hallman and a string of other coaches didn't dampen our support. We have watched many losing Tiger teams. Back in the day, an 8 win season would have made most people happy and any bowl was a big thing back then. Beating Wyoming in a bowl one year was a beautiful thing. We weren't spoiled little cry babies that think every year if we don't win the SEC or national championship that we are somehow failures. Back the team. All this negativity hurts our look as fans. This generation has destroyed the true spirit of Tiger stadium. Can't stay past halftime. Sickening.


The more I re-read this the more I don't think you see what you've done here. I realize you think you're pointing out that there was a time when winning wasn't the ONLY thing we cared about and that even during those days between titles we had lots to celebrate.

And that's all true.

But what you're also doing is completely and totally downplaying the difference between existing and thriving as a program. Yes...we had great moments and wonderful players prior to 2000. But for much of that time we were not much more than an also-ran nationally. And even THEN, as much fun as we were having...we hoped for more. We watched programs like Nebraska wax us time and again in bowls and wondered when it would be our time. We watched teams that were nobodies in Florida State and Miami and even Florida rise up and win titles while we sank.

Then things changed with Saban coming and they REALLY changed for good on January 4th, 2004. It was not just hoping anymore...we'd done it. Saban showed us that all those things we said to ourselves really COULD happen...if we did the right things and really made an effort to take care of what we had.

So I think you're missing the point here. I don't think there's anyone that can;t look back nostalgically at the old days and remember them fondly. But are you REALLY wishing things were like they used to be...when we "had fun" getting are heads beaten in on road trips to BAMA? Being "happy" about 8 win seasons...when we now have a program that's average 10 over the past decade? Going to ANY bowl?

No...those were fine enough to wish for back then, because it was, unfortunately, as much as we could hope for given what we had. But we're not that program any more...thank goodness. We're better, we're beyond it, we're above it. And with that comes higher levels of expectations. That's not being spoiled, it's being realistic about what this program CAN achieve and doing everything we can to ensure we stay in a position to achieve them.

Read in the wrong light, your post really does seem to read as if you'd prefer to go back to 1975 when winning was great but it wasn't the real point of the endeavor on Saturday Night's in Death Valley.

Personally, I would not. That's not to say that I would not like more fans to find some of the same enjoyment we used to in the OTHER things that make our program so special. But the idea that we ought not have high expectations because we once sucked and we still had fun makes it seem as if those concepts are mutually exclusive...and they are not.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram