re: Better in their prime : Favre or Rodgers?

This is tough because on one hand, I'm of the opinion that Rodgers is basically the Lebron of the QB position. He's perfect. Big arm, pinpoint accuracy, mobile, and durable. He takes hit after hit and not like Peyton Manning where he folds up bracing for contact.

On the other hand, Favre pre Manning and Brady was basically what we think of Rodgers today. Big arm, pinpoint accuracy, mobile, and durable. You don't just luck into MVPs.

Ultimately Rodgers has the far and away edge in not committing turnovers which does it for me.