Started By
Message

re: LSU vs. Alabama in the QB department, Nick Saban holds the key!

Posted on 12/1/15 at 8:01 am to
Posted by Cs
Member since Aug 2008
10481 posts
Posted on 12/1/15 at 8:01 am to
quote:

Saban has the key, veteran QB's with experience.


AJ McCarron won the national title in his first year as a starter.

Blake Sims took Alabama to the playoffs last year in his first year as a starter.

Jake Coker is taking Alabama to the playoffs this year in his first year as a starter.

All of these quarterbacks had less experience than both Jennings and Harris coming into this year.
Posted by DoesLSUevenQBbro
Virginia Beach, VA
Member since Nov 2015
327 posts
Posted on 12/1/15 at 8:10 am to
quote:

All of these quarterbacks had less experience than both Jennings and Harris coming into this year.


Game experience-yes
But time in the program, time with the offense-no
Posted by emanresu
Member since Dec 2009
9397 posts
Posted on 12/1/15 at 8:12 am to
quote:

All of these quarterbacks had less experience than both Jennings and Harris coming into this year.

Yes, and there's a big difference between a true freshman/sophomore starter with no experience and a redshirt soph/junior/senior starting with no experience.
Posted by Salviati
Member since Apr 2006
5581 posts
Posted on 12/1/15 at 8:13 am to
quote:

AJ McCarron won the national title in his first year as a starter.

Blake Sims took Alabama to the playoffs last year in his first year as a starter.

Jake Coker is taking Alabama to the playoffs this year in his first year as a starter.

All of these quarterbacks had less experience than both Jennings and Harris coming into this year.
Like so many other fans, you place too big of a limitation on the word "experience."

You think QBs can only gain experience and learn in games. bullshite.

You think QBs can only gain experience and develop as passers if they pass in games. bullshite.

QBs, like every other position, learn and develop their skills in practice, the film room, and the coach's classroom.
Mechanics are honed and fixed in practice, the film room, and the coach's classroom.
Decision making is taught and crafted in practice, the film room, and the coach's classroom.

In practice, the film room, and the coach's classroom, the coach can focus on and correct problems: mental, physical, and mechanical.

QBs acquire experience through practice, the film room, and the coach's classroom. The more years a QB has on campus, the more time the QB spends in practice, the film room, and coach's classroom. Thus, more years in college equals better developed QB.
Posted by Tiger Voodoo
Champs 03 07 09 11(fack) 19!!!
Member since Mar 2007
21788 posts
Posted on 12/1/15 at 8:16 am to
quote:

AJ McCarron won the national title in his first year as a starter. Blake Sims took Alabama to the playoffs last year in his first year as a starter. Jake Coker is taking Alabama to the playoffs this year in his first year as a starter. All of these quarterbacks had less experience than both Jennings and Harris coming into this year.



You're using a different definition of "experience" than the OP. Years in college matter when talking about a QBs ability to succeed. Whether they were playing or not, and in LSUs case it seems that early playing time is actually what is most harmful to a QB.

McCarron was in his third year on campus, Sims his fifth, and Coker is also five years out of HS, though it's only his second at Bama.

But sitting for two years to watch and learn is a very good thing for a QB most of the time, and the inability of LSU to bring QBs along slowly has likely been a major factor in many of them being shellshocked that limits their overall ability to improve.

We saw the benefits of a slow progression with Flynn and even as the previous posting pointed out, Mett.

Posted by Powerman
Member since Jan 2004
162258 posts
Posted on 12/1/15 at 8:17 am to
quote:

All of these quarterbacks had less experience than both Jennings and Harris coming into this year.


Less game experience yes. But they've been learning in practice and in film rooms. Also more physically ready after more years in their S and C program.

first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram