re: How hard is it to understand, "Miles' offense" isn't the problem. Having a QB is

Once again, not all first time starters are not created equally. Almost all of the guys you posted were 3rd or more year players. Winston being an exception in that he was just fantastic that year.

But I don't think simply grabbing the starters from the past SEC / BCS championships tells the whole story. Those were clearly already all great teams.