re: Gen. Douglas MacArthur "dug out dug"

quote:

---

I would argue that Grant, Washington, Eisenhower, and Patton are better "men-at-arms"

---

Let's not confuse the generals (who are important, no question) and the real men doing the real fighting.

Audie Murphy is probably the greatest "man-at-arms" we've ever produced - because he so routinely demonstrated courage under fire, I believe his awards are actually understated (despite being the most decorated U.S. soldier of WWII) - he should have received 2 CMH, 1 DSC and 1 SS, as opposed to 1 CMH, 1 DSC and 2 SS - but when we're making that distinction, it's hard to argue against his courage and capability under fire.

Anyone can be brave (and get killed quickly) - anyone can develop some proficiency at arms - very few develop both to the level of success achieved by Murphy, be so effective on the battlefield and live to tell the tale.

Just my $0.02.