Started By
Message

re: Have to do a speech on why college athletes should NOT get paid.

Posted on 4/20/15 at 9:47 am to
Posted by WG_Dawg
Hoover
Member since Jun 2004
86553 posts
Posted on 4/20/15 at 9:47 am to
-it's amateur athletics (supposed to be anyway, that's a separate debate entirely). Getting paid just futher blurs the line between them being true "student athletes" and basically minor league players
-their tuition, books, food, housing, and everything else is already covered. They're walking away from school with probably over $100K in free benefits
-it's a slippery slope to go down. Let's say every player gets X amount of money. Ok...so in a few years what happens when your heisman winning QB complains that he makes as much as the backup punter? Eventually it could lead to price disparity which is just going to be a battle that no real CFB should want
-If the football players are getting paid, every athlete on all mens and womens teams need to get paid as well. So see point above, how do you determine how much the QB makes compared to the backup singles player on the womens tennis team?
-If schools are allowed to come up with their own system, the big money schools are going to further distance themselves from the smaller schools. The playing field will become even more uneven.
-It opens up shady behavior even moreso than it alreayd is. Your big time athletes can buy a brand new car, take pics with a handful of hundreds, buy out the bar eveyr saturday night, etc. When questioned they can simply say "it's my stipend money". Basically these under the table deals will ramp up considerably because now the players actually WOULD have an excuse for how they are spending all this money.


I'm not naive, I realize that hte game today is nothing like it was 30 years ago. But there still should be a line drawn where these 18-21 year olds are supposed to be going to school, going to class, and playing football on the weekends. It shouldn't turn into even more of a farm system.
Posted by undecided
Member since May 2012
15492 posts
Posted on 4/20/15 at 9:52 am to
quote:

If the football players are getting paid, every athlete on all mens and womens teams need to get paid as well.

No they don't. When they bring in as much money as football, basketball, and to a lesser extent baseball players do then they can be paid. Until then they should be happy for the Big3 revenue that subsidizes their scholarships and STFU
quote:

-If schools are allowed to come up with their own system, the big money schools are going to further distance themselves from the smaller schools. The playing field will become even more uneven.

Would like to see this happen in football tbh. Somehow create an NCAA tourney type environment where the best of the Power 5 go against the top of the CUSA, American, Sunbelt ect. Schools would split tv revenue money and everyone would be happy.
quote:

-It opens up shady behavior even moreso than it alreayd is. Your big time athletes can buy a brand new car, take pics with a handful of hundreds, buy out the bar eveyr saturday night, etc. When questioned they can simply say "it's my stipend money". Basically these under the table deals will ramp up considerably because now the players actually WOULD have an excuse for how they are spending all this money.

There has been shady behavior in college athletics since it's inception. It will not go away. And if some 50 year-old, rich, white, guy gets his rocks off by giving his money away to college athletes then more power to him
This post was edited on 4/20/15 at 9:56 am
Posted by FairhopeTider
Fairhope, Alabama
Member since May 2012
20797 posts
Posted on 4/20/15 at 11:05 am to
quote:

-it's a slippery slope to go down. Let's say every player gets X amount of money. Ok...so in a few years what happens when your heisman winning QB complains that he makes as much as the backup punter? Eventually it could lead to price disparity which is just going to be a battle that no real CFB should want


Nobody talks about this point and its one of the biggest ones IMO. How do you determine which player gets paid a certain amount? You can't. A Freshman 5 Star QB can come in and have tons of jersey sales and get paid without ever playing a down while a the 5th Year All American OG could potentially not get a dime. Could an athlete sue if he feels the school is not compensating him with the correct proportion of of his value for the team? Could a player have grounds to transfer without sitting out if he thinks another player at his position is getting unjustly paid more? Say goodbye to any kind of team chemistry.

Great points all around though. When people say schools make all of this money off the backs of these athletes, they usually cry about the Manziel types who are the stars. For every one of him, there are a few hundred whoare nameless. So this whole issue is about compensating a handful of players out of several thousand every year.
This post was edited on 4/20/15 at 11:16 am
Posted by TigerBait1127
Houston
Member since Jun 2005
47336 posts
Posted on 4/20/15 at 11:25 am to
quote:

-it's a slippery slope to go down. Let's say every player gets X amount of money. Ok...so in a few years what happens when your heisman winning QB complains that he makes as much as the backup punter? Eventually it could lead to price disparity which is just going to be a battle that no real CFB should want


This isn't a valid reason to be against it and is fallacious.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram