re: Finished Lost

I have already acknowledged that, that is what the writers have said. We can have a discussion about the world of lost and it's rules and what makes sense there, which is what I was doing. Interpreting what I saw.

If you want to talk about the reality of creating a TV show and making creative decisions, that is a separate argument. I have already said I think it is possible the writers went this way for reasons other than those that make sense in the world of lost, namely all of the predictions that the island was purgatory. Fact is the writers made a decision at some time and I don't know when or why. Only know that after the fact, they claim they were alive on the island.