re: Creepiest urban legends...

Read one of these stories where a woman actually let a young boy and younger girl in after initially being hesitant. The initial request was to use the phone. The boy was eating an apple and when the phone request didn't initially work because the woman offered to call their mom he asked to come in to get ketchup for his apple. That didn't work and he said the little girl with him needed to use the bathroom. She let them in and when she followed the boy into the house she then noticed his solid black eyes. The boy turned to her and said he was there to "collect her. Freaked out by this she hauled tail out of the house to a neighbor. The neighbor and her went back and found nothing except for A partially eaten apple in the hallway.