Which 5 would you keep of these - Baseball?

I give up the draft slot for the player:

Cutch - 2nd rounder (duh)

Beltre - 4th rounder (less certain because of age but still great value)

Verlander - 5th rounder (probably right where he'd be drafted, I'd think)

Heyward - 8th rounder (probably a little later than he'd be drafted)

Wil Myers - 20th rounder (great value, duh pick IMO)

Starling Marte - 24th rounder (great value, duh pick IMO)

Could also pay a 1st for Felix or a 3rd for Price, but values seem a little high for those two.

ETA:

Right now I have Cutch, Beltre, Verlander, Myers, Marte.