re: Anyone seen this? Geno Smith absolutely trashed by Draft Analyst

quote:

---

what don't you agree with? that Matt Barkley can make all the throws? that's all college football and NFL scouts have been saying about him since he was in high school.

---

Show me one person (pundit, scout - whoever) that has said Geno Smith can't make every NFL throw. There isn't one.

And most have said Geno's overall throwing ability (accuracy, velocity, etc) are best of the bunch, including Barkley. Just because Geno threw primarily short throws in college thanks to the offense he played in does not mean he can't make every big down-field throw asked of him. As SCH has pointed out - if you have watched him play this year you would know this from seeing it with your own two eyes.