Started By
Message

re: Tevin Lawson to accept greyshirt?

Posted on 2/21/13 at 8:15 am to
Posted by Indiana Tiger
Member since Feb 2005
4057 posts
Posted on 2/21/13 at 8:15 am to
quote:

If the SEC has its members operating under a different set of rules than the NCAA, why is it not noted in the conference bylaws?

I don't know. Personally think it was bad rule writing. You have to remember that it was the SEC that wrote the rule for the express purpose of limiting the signing of unqualified athletes. The emphasis on the LOI is more consistent with this intent.

quote:

How can they enforce a rule that doesn't officially exist?

The member universities are the SEC. They can implement the rules however they want (as long as they are more restrictive). It could just be a gentlemen's agreement.

quote:

Also, LSU accepted 24 LOIs in 2012 and three did not qualify. How were we recently able to add 27 instead of 26?

Are you sure they didn't count back 1 to 2011? Hill participated in the spring game.

There are tons of circumstantial evidence that the LOI interpretation is how it is being done in practice. I have seen zero evidence contrary to it.
Posted by MOT
Member since Jul 2006
27911 posts
Posted on 2/21/13 at 8:51 am to
You are correct in that the SEC originally did it because so many players were being signed knowing they would not qualify. Some schools were signing 35 players knowing many of them had no chance and were going to juco. The new rule has eliminated that practice. That's why LSU did not accept LOIs from players like John Thomas. But I still think if it was intended to join the initial counter limit and the signee limit at the hip, it would specifically be stated that way.

quote:

The member universities are the SEC. They can implement the rules however they want (as long as they are more restrictive).

I agree completely, just pointing out that when they have previously differed or been more restrictive they have specifically stated the differences in their operating bylaws. They have not done so in this case.

quote:

Are you sure they didn't count back 1 to 2011? Hill participated in the spring game.

I'm not sure, I would have to revisit the 2011 class. I do know that was the one with the self imposed restriction due to the Hicks/NCAA investigation.

quote:

There are tons of circumstantial evidence that the LOI interpretation is how it is being done in practice. I have seen zero evidence contrary to it.

What other evidence is there? I know there is LSU's situation with this most recent class, but that alone doesn't convince me for a few different reasons. The only other thing I'm aware of is an article about a year ago inferred this interpretation based on a quote from an SEC official that most likely was in reference to another rule.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram