Will we ever see the Dune series get the treatment it deserves? - Page 2 - TigerDroppings.com

Posted byMessage
boxcarbarney
LSU Fan
I like pie.
Member since Jul 2007
9311 posts

re: Will we ever see the Dune series get the treatment it deserves?


quote:

There were 6 books. He died before he finished the 7th book. His son and some hack took the notes for the 7th book and split it into 2 books to finish the series. It was painful for me to read. Like I said, I don't trust that they successfully conveyed the correct story. It was better than nothing though I guess.

I wish that I could just get Frank Herbert's original notes and make my own decision about where he wanted to take the story. If a miniseries was to be made, I think that basing it off of the notes would come out better than basing it on the abomination that was Hunters of Dune and Sandworms of Dune


Can we talk a little about how shitty Brian Herbert's treatment of Dune has been? I actually liked the prequel novels (House Atreides, Harkonnen, and Corrino). But, the Butlerian Jihad books just sucked.

Then they tried to shoehorn novels in between the original books.

And the abortion that was Sandworms and Hunters of Dune. Its like the last two books were just and excuse for B. Herbert to stick all the silly bull shite from his previous books into the ending of Dune.

We could have done without the fricking sandworms that can now swim. We could have done without bringing back every main character from the original novel as ghola's. Omnius and Erasmus were just fricking annoying.

When I finished Chapterhouse: Dune, I got really interested in the Facedancers who appeared to be controlling things behind the scenes. Who were these people? What did they want? Did the Facedancers break away from the Tleilaxu and form a superior race? Fascinating stuff.

Then Brian Hebert had to frick it all up by making them Omnius and Erasmus role playing. frick!

And don't even get me started on the whole Norma Cenva being some sort of Guild Navigator diety retardedness.

I'm actually reading Sisterhood of Dune right now. And its more of the same shite. Here you have this vast universe that Herbert and Anderson are fricking up with their silliness.

Anyway, to answer the OP, I would love to see a dedicated Dune movie/mini series. The Sci Fi versions were ok, but still didn't provide that sense of depth that the novels had.






Back to top
prplhze2000
LSU Fan
Parts Unknown
Member since Jan 2007
31087 posts
 Online 

re: Will we ever see the Dune series get the treatment it deserves?


You could tell in Chapterhouse things were not right. Alot didn't add up and mesh with previous books. Duncan goes from being some badass in his new body every BG is scared of to being a pussy. Same thing with Teg. Very little action in the book. Alot of debate and that is about it.





Back to top
picknroll
LSU Fan
Member since Apr 2012
81 posts

re: Will we ever see the Dune series get the treatment it deserves?


What were the other sisters called?





Back to top
boxcarbarney
LSU Fan
I like pie.
Member since Jul 2007
9311 posts

re: Will we ever see the Dune series get the treatment it deserves?


You mean the Honored Matres?





Back to top
boxcarbarney
LSU Fan
I like pie.
Member since Jul 2007
9311 posts

re: Will we ever see the Dune series get the treatment it deserves?


I really think that Frank Herbert was building up to.something big for the next book(s).





Back to top
prplhze2000
LSU Fan
Parts Unknown
Member since Jan 2007
31087 posts
 Online 

re: Will we ever see the Dune series get the treatment it deserves?


yeah. Did a horrible job of explaining them. Everything was in the No Ship. Reminds me of Man with the Golden Gun, sick author and book is incomplete when he dies.





Back to top


Back to top




//