re: Whiskey/Bourbon/Scotch appreciation thread

I compared the Balvenie Doublewood to the Carribean Cask tonight. I probably need to spend more time on the Carribean Cask since I am almost finished with the doublewood bottle, but I think I preferred the doublewood. It had a more intense, smokey flavor. The Carribean Cask was still very good and you can really taste the rum. Both are great, but the nod goes to DW ( it's cheaper too).