re: If Andrew Luck Wins the Rookie of the Year

quote:

---

2 wins to 9 wins

Nuff said.

---

That's a fair point. (Even though wins are a team stat, not a player stat)

But you are kidding yourself if you think the Colts and Redskins played comparable schedules. The Colts schedule is a joke. Tennessee twice. Jacksonville twice. Miami, Minnesota, Cleveland, N.Y. Jets, Buffalo, Detroit.

Here are his results against teams that actually can win games:

41-21 Loss to Chicago
27-30 Win over Green Bay (Not bad)
59-24 Loss to New England
29-17 Loss to Houston

A really glaring loss: 35-9 to the Jets.

They are guaranteed one more win when they play the damn chiefs.

The Skins, on the other hand, have played the Giants twice, Pittsburgh, Baltimore, Dallas, Atlanta, and will play the Cowboys again.

Luck has played 4 goods teams, while the Skins have played 6. I think that should cover the discrepency in the records of the two, which is only different by one game.

Also, the Skins have yet to lose a game by 35, or 26, their biggest margin of loss being 15.

I just thought we should get all that shite straightened out if you really want to use a team stat to argue that Luck has had a better year, which based on player stats he hasn't