1st off, I'm not the person that proposed the change, Jimbeam did. LINK

Capt ST (Team old School is in the lead & killed 0 geese) & AboveGroundPool (who is on your team) also agreed with this rule change.

Nobody objected to this until I killed 4 specks on opening weekend.

There is only 1 fair way to decide this. We have 25 people in this contest. Vote & marjority rules.

Everyone please post what you prefer. Dark geese go to 3 points or stay at 5. If there is a change, it's not going to be retroactive. Points already on the board will remain on the board.

Keep dark geese at 5 points

jsmoke222000
MrCoachKlein
tkr1407
AboveGroundPool
jimbeam

Change dark geese to 3 points

jimjackandjose
34venture
Choirboy
DeepSouthSportsman
guesswho
Capt ST
CootKilla
BourgsTheWord
TulaneUVA

Members who need still need to vote

GREENHEAD22
fishfighter
Vol Fan in the Bayou
TXGunslinger10
nathannb22
Pintail
rruss14
Bu-Yah!
LSUballs
bossflossjr
MSWebfoot

This post was edited on 11/13/12 at 9:49 am

3 ...

Report Post

Posted by jimjackandjose

Member since Jun 2011

6501 posts

Posted on 11/13/12 at 7:41 am to jsmoke222000

Fair enough.

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by MrCoachKlein

Member since Sep 2010

10302 posts

Posted on 11/13/12 at 7:51 am to jsmoke222000

Regardless of whether or not Jsmoke killed 4 this past weekend, IMO Specks are high quality waterfowl and should hold just as much value as any other "trophy" in this contest. The same argument can be made that guys hunting timber will have an advantage with the mallards. Plus, you can only kill 2 anyway, I really don't see what the big deal is here.

**EDIT**

Just realized that mallards were 2 points and specks were 5 points, I thought they were the same value. I say dark geese and mallards/ sprigs/ canvasbacks should be worth the same, but it would be much easier to just make all dark geese and big ducks worth 2

This post was edited on 11/13/12 at 7:59 am

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by 34venture

Buffer Zone

Member since Mar 2010

11369 posts

Posted on 11/13/12 at 7:53 am to jsmoke222000

Geese 3

And while we at it greenheads should be 3 as well. This way those who don't have geese still have the chance to score big.

2 ...

Report Post

Outdoor Board - Replies to Post