re: Help!! Handgun question

quote:

---

Precision of the pistol wins out there. Why you even brought a battle rifle (which would be chambered in .308 or similarly way-too-fricking-large-for-home-defense- caliber I do not understand. Again apples to oranges.

---

I guess this would be what the definition of "battle rifle" really is. The reason I say battle rifle is because "assault" rifle has negative connotations and assumes the gun is fully automatic. I was referring to an AR15 in 5.56/.223. I agree that a .308 is way too bulky for a home defense caliber.

quote:

---

You are claiming that the spread and initial energy from a shotgun is the kicker for making it a better choice than a pistol.

---

I think it's better due to higher muzzle energy, larger shot pattern, and the fact that it is on your shoulder and not extended. If we get into a conversation about a more precise shot, I can agree a handgun would be slightly better. This is why I have both next to my bed (870 and Beretta 96).

quote:

---

Sorry if I have offended you love for the smooth bore, but I was not advising against a shotgun or saying it was a poor choice for home defense. I was simply saying i would get the revolver if the OP is looking for a pistol as a home defense option.

---

None taken. A healthy argument is no cause for concern (this isn't the OT FWIW). I definitely agree a .38/.357 full sized revolver would be great for a new shooter.