re: Crackpot ASOIAF Theories SPOILERS

quote:

---

Jon wasn't born in the North but he's a Snow. I'm thinking it's where the father is from.

---

I'm thinking his mother was from the North and his father was from Dragonstone.

quote:

---

But even if we don't know for sure where he was born, we know for sure he wasn't born in the North. Ned was fighting in the south during the rebellion. It's not like he asked for Robert for 3 months off, rode north, knocked up some woman, and went south to rejoin the war.

---

Didn't Wyman Manderly claim that when Robert sent Ned to the North to secure an alliance with some lord is when he conceived Jon Snow? That is in the chapter that says Jon Snow is named after Jon Arryn.