re: anyone fish Elmers island?

Took my wife and kids the last two months on my days off. It's a dirtier beach than the state park (think sea weed and dead fish), but you can just drive right on it. No hauling gear and everything, which with a wife and 2 kids was a plus for me. You can find some clean spots though.

Just you and your wife, it shouldn't be that much gear. So if she wants a cleaner beach then go to the park.