re: How meaningful are STARS? Player evaluations

You can't put too much into the star/ranking system. It's a good guide, but not a hard line rule.

I don't put much of anything into the class rankings. Not a lot seperates the top ten ranked schools and hardly anything seperates the top five. There probably is a bigger difference between the school ranked #5 and ranked #25 though.

As for the individual player rankings, its a guess, albeit usually an educated guess, but its still a good guideline. Not a Rule.