Alternate Walking Dead Scene That Could Have Been

There is a little bit of pronoun confusion there. But it seems he is saying that Shane was basically on a suicide mission for the good of the group I'm assuming. That would have been a cool twist.

Not to be a cynic, but for me that would've been a stupid twist. No one was more about self preservation than Shane, and he went out of his way several times to show that he would've been a better leader than Rick after Z Day, that Lori would've been better protected with him vs. Rick. Plus, he was obsessed/in love with Lori.

It would've seemed way out of character (for me) to see him suddenly have this suicidal/benevolent moment.

quote:

---

The idea was that Shane had never intended to kill Rick at all, but had brought Rick out into the woods to kill him. Jon Bernthal is convinced that Shane knew he was a cancer to the group and that he had to go. He just wanted Carl and Lori to be safe and for Rick to man up and take the role he was supposed to take. He said he truly believes that Shane was never as heartless as he wanted to appear that he was, and that's what makes him so entertaining to watch."

---

This is the theory I've had all along. Shane wanted Rick to do what was right and never intended on killing Rick to begin with.

If you go back and watch the first season, Shane wasn't a bad guy. Other than the scene where he held the scope on Rick in the woods (and I guess the scene when he drunkenly tried bang Lori again), there was no indication of Shane being a bad guy until he killed Otis.

As he sincerely said to Rick in season 2, he was confused because the world had gone mad. He did what was right by taking in his best friend's family and mistakenly fell in love in the process. And Lori is the reason that dude snapped. He truly thought Rick was dead and when he showed up for the first time in season 1, Lori completely turned on Shane and that played a huge role in Shane's sudden transformation.