Started By
Message
locked post

Listing of the Pros and Cons of Les Miles as HC

Posted on 11/2/10 at 1:07 pm
Posted by slackster
Houston
Member since Mar 2009
85389 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 1:07 pm
Everyone seems to get all excited and throw out meaningless drivel when they discuss Miles and his future at LSU. Well, lets try to list the pros and cons of Les Miles as HC and what he brings to the entire program. If it is a pro/con that is absurd, I will not list it. Some items can arguably be on either side, and if that is the case, I will list them as such. I will try and keep up with people's suggestions. Please, do not hijack the thread and bitch about someone's suggestion. Just list things you would like to see added to the Pro side and what should be added to the Con side.

Once we have established a comprehensive list, we can engage in a more constructive debate. If you want Miles gone, you will have to address as many Cons as possible while maintaining as many Pros as possible. Vice versa if you want Miles to stay. I will get the list started.

Pros:
Violation-free program
Realistically expect 9+ wins a year
Realistically expect Top 5 Recruiting classes(Family man included in this pro)
Realistically expect SEC West every 4 years
Realistically expect SEC Champion every 6 years
Some great assistant coaches
Ingenious quotes
4th quarter fireworks
Player loyalty
Bowl-game preperation
Hardly ever get blown out/Hang close as underdog
Added: Don't expect his name to come up on a whole lot of coaching vacancy short lists unlike Saban whose name was brought up every 3 months


Cons:
Player loyalty
Some questionable assitant coaches
Realistically expect 2+ loss each year
Realistically expect 1+ loss as a favorite
Realistically expect problems to be addressed ONLY at the end of the season
Idiotic quotes
4th quarter fireworks
Questionable in-game coaching
Hardly ever blow someone out/keep it close as favorite
Added: Don't expect his name to come up on a whole lot of coaching vacancy short lists

This post was edited on 11/5/10 at 5:16 pm
Posted by graychef
Member since Jun 2008
28373 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 1:09 pm to
quote:

Questionable in-game coaching


You are too kind.
Posted by RealityTiger
Geismar, LA
Member since Jan 2010
20462 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 1:12 pm to
Pros: Don't expect his name to come up on a whole lot of coaching vacancy short lists unlike Saban whose name was brought up every 3 months

Cons: Don't expect his name to come up on a whole lot of coaching vacancy short lists
Posted by The312
I Live in The Three One Two
Member since Aug 2008
6967 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 1:28 pm to
Pros

Recruiting

Cons

Everything else

(P.S. A list of Pros and Cons should actually be relevant to the assessment being undertaken. Thus, "family man" should be stricken from your list. The fact that Miles is a family man is completely unrelated to his abilities as a college football coach.)
Posted by josh336
baton rouge
Member since Jan 2007
78084 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 1:29 pm to
Does "family man" really belong a Pros list? How is that related to coaching football?
Posted by josh336
baton rouge
Member since Jan 2007
78084 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 1:30 pm to
quote:

Realistically expect 1+ loss each year

Should be changed to 2, when has he lost less than 2?
Posted by CptBengal
BR Baby
Member since Dec 2007
71661 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 1:54 pm to
quote:

Realistically expect SEC West every 4 years


really, every 4 years? So if we don't win this year (doubtful) we DEFINITELY will win next year? GTFO.

quote:

Realistically expect SEC Champion every 6 years


Again, really? How do you come up with this "realistic" expectation?

quote:

Some great assistant coaches


how many different assistant coaches has he hired? How good have they been?
Posted by Topwater Trout
Red Stick
Member since Oct 2010
67601 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 1:57 pm to
Pros

1. W-L record
2. Recruiting
3. With a month to prepare his teams play well

Cons
1. Recruiting-gets too much credit for recruting a state rich in talent and facilites are 2nd to none. Everyone wants to say what did Hallman and Dinardo do etc....well LSU was not a powerhouse and did not have the facilities it has now.
2. Clock management
3. Gameday coaching
4. Interviews
5. Player loyalty- an obvious hinderance considering he remains loyal to players that are not producing.
6. Indecisive- kept GC too long!

Posted by josh336
baton rouge
Member since Jan 2007
78084 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 2:16 pm to
I'd add "makes question assitant hires"

Examples:
Gary Crowton
Mallveto
Billy G. to this point
Posted by josh336
baton rouge
Member since Jan 2007
78084 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 2:19 pm to
Clock Management belongs at the top of this list
Posted by DaSaltyTiger
Alexandria/Pineville, LA area
Member since Dec 2004
4689 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 2:45 pm to
If you are looking for a perfect program every year, it's not going to happen. No one has that sort of advantage these days. It has been a long time since I played organized football, but I still remember my days in high school and college. When you have 11 folks on the field that have to click together to make a play happen successfully, it is not going to happen each and every snap. Moreover, there are going to be some opponents who are simply going to be better. It may not be a spectacular team but it is still 7-1 and in the top 12 in the country. There are a lot of other teams out there that are not.
Posted by peopleschamp
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2006
6576 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 4:05 pm to
I am not trying to be a smartass, but I don't see Les winning another SEC Championship again while at LSU. The league is too competitive for Les now. I don't even have the expectation he will win another West Title. I would say SEC every 10 years and West every 5 and that is generous I think.
Posted by RogerTheShrubber
Juneau, AK
Member since Jan 2009
262334 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 7:08 pm to
Pros: 8-10 wins a year.
Recruits well
Keeps LSU in the national spotlight
Beats the teams he is supposed to, with few exceptions

Cons: Seems to be a ceiling on the level he can take a team, without a LOT of help ('07)
Loses to teams he is supposed to lose to
Player development sucks
Too loyal to crappy assistants
Can be embarrassing to the fan base
Is exasperating.

Posted by TigerBandAlumnus82
Pensacola,FL
Member since Jul 2007
3104 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 8:58 pm to
quote:

Cons:
Player loyalty
Some questionable assitant coaches
Realistically expect 2+ loss each year
Realistically expect 1+ loss as a favorite
Realistically expect problems to be addressed ONLY at the end of the season
Idiotic quotes
4th quarter fireworks
Questionable in-game coaching
Hardly ever blow someone out/keep it close as favorite
Added: Don't expect his name to come up on a whole lot of coaching vacancy short lists

* Hires and keeps weak assistants too long.
DING DING DING DING. (Peveto, Mallory, Lane, Yanowsky, McCarthy, Studrawa, Crowton)
Jury still out on Haley, Gonzales, Wilson and Ensminger.

Add these......

* No dedicated QB coach which the program needs.
* Weak QB and OL recruiting.
* "Unbalanced" recruiting classes that are far too heavily weighted towards speed and athleticism. Not enough "Smart football players that make plays" types. Doesn't understand that you need a good balance of both to compete for National Championships.
* Lack of discipline, organization and attention to the little details that keep a program at an elite level over the long haul.
* Questionable player personnel evaluator (Especially at the QB/OL positions)
* Embarrassingly bad public speaker.........
Posted by LSUMafia
Member since May 2005
9862 posts
Posted on 11/2/10 at 10:47 pm to
Just to clarify some of your points:

For your pros:

LSU is not violation-free under Miles

I don't see how anyone can honestly say right now it is realistically expected to win the West or the SEC in any time period under him anymore given the last 3 years.

Cons:
Guaranteed at least 2 losses per year. He's never proven he can lose less than 2 even in his best years.

Clock Management

Player development

Unequal Accountability

Questionable recruiting of certain positions such as QB

Requires tons of help from his Assistants and brings little to the table like a Meyer on O and Saban on D, thus requiring tons of money having to be spent on coordinators and assistants.

Posted by TigerFan55555
Tomball, TX
Member since Nov 2008
9604 posts
Posted on 11/3/10 at 8:19 am to
i think their are way to many pros on that list....and not enough cons...Face it, damn near any coach could have had his record at LSU when Saban left the cupboard full as can be...Most of the people who know and can jugde talent, (whether it be coaching or players) has seen this coming for a long time....face it the man is not a good coach....lucky is an understatement...


his inability to see that Jefferson is the worst QB to ever come out of LSU and continues to start him is beyond the stupidity of pee wee herman.....and thats enough for me to consider him the ultimate dumbass....

fire his arse and let TAF pay the bill....what you would get in one BCS game would cover it...and if you think a new coach couldnt take LSU to the BCS next year, your nuts...were loaded...
Posted by LSU GrandDad
houston, texas
Member since Jun 2009
21564 posts
Posted on 11/3/10 at 8:52 am to
Pro: his graduation rate is great (esp reletive to previous hc's)

Con: too loyal to asst.s ; he needs to demand more from them, esp since he's a ceo type of coach. our OL coach should not be here this year. not sure about WR coach, but i'm leaning that way. as far as OC. definately a goner.
Posted by LouisianaLonghorn
Austin, Texas
Member since Jan 2006
14243 posts
Posted on 11/3/10 at 11:23 am to
quote:

Questionable in-game coaching


I would add to this the fact that he seldom, if ever, makes adjustments at halftime.
Posted by captcouv
Brusly
Member since Oct 2005
217 posts
Posted on 11/3/10 at 4:00 pm to
Pro - Assistant Coaches love to come work for the guy. Makes Head Coaches.
Posted by Genghis Khan
Mongolia
Member since Nov 2008
1653 posts
Posted on 11/3/10 at 8:32 pm to
Prose
Good contract negotiator
Good recruiter
&
Cons
Poor game management
Poor gameplan developer
Poor halftime adjustments
Poor player development


first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram