re: What grade would you give

For a rookie QB I give him a solid B. He had his ups and downs, but if you look at it from the point of view of him being a rookie you have to be impressed.

He didn't go out and whip anyone single handed, but he was also not asked to. He stayed within his tools and that is a good sign of maturity.

I don't think he's the next Brees or Manning, but he's going to be a solid QB for a while in the league if he continues to progress the way he did this year.