re: Good pair of waterproof hiking shoes?

If you want to do more than tally up miles I'd look at approach shoes.

A great many are waterproof, they most all have excellent ankle support, and trail runners won't have near the traction when it's rough and steep. As said fit is going to vary by brand and your foot. And weight is going to vary greatly from extremely light to more warm and heavy. My last few in past order have been Salewa, Sportiva, and Scarpa's.

The key for me is to switch out to different night shoes so the day one's can be opened up an left to dry.