Started By
Message

re: Boom #1 *Disregard, Offical TD Talent Evaluator, NotAStarGazer says he won't start at LSU*

Posted on 3/11/24 at 7:57 pm to
Posted by BackwardsLs
Member since Dec 2022
28 posts
Posted on 3/11/24 at 7:57 pm to
I have no issue with your opinion, you're entitled to it just as everyone else is. I'm not narrow-minded, I (and everyone else) just said you should wait to see how he develops as a SR before (objectively) stating that he will never start a game at LSU based on your analysis of his film. That is being narrow-minded.

1. You stated that because a majority of the 125 FBS teams have not offered Ross, he will not be an impact player at LSU. My point was (and you noted in your response) that most schools realize they would just be wasting resources so strictly looking at an offer sheet is not a fair assessment. Players also embellish their offer lists and report offers they do not have. Schools dive into film and throw out tons of offers after JR seasons and his offer list has grown recently and will certainly continue to grow.

2. Recruiting services do not hit on 83-89% of all players in a given class. Far from it.

3. Right, but even though they only cover one state, they still have less eyes on these players than On3, 247, etc. and are subject to misses just as frequently if not more than those services because of the resources available to them. No one is perfect in this industry.

4. That's fine, your definition of explosiveness is different than mine (and everyone else in this thread and multiple HS coach's/talent evaluator's opinions on other forums who rave about his "explosiveness", ability to shed blocks, cover, blitz, etc.) and that's fair. Straight-line speed and lateral agility, short area burst, etc. are all very different and I recognize that. But for a kid his size, who will still get bigger, he seems to be at least above average on all fronts and projects to continue to get better.

I'm acknowledging that he might be the best LB ever at LSU, he might be the worst LB ever at LSU, ORRRR he might fall somewhere in between, but definitely stating that he will never start a game at LSU based on JR highlights is jumping the gun 100%. No one knows how he will develop; you gave your opinion (dozens of times) so we know where you stand. The horse is dead, no need to beat it further. By the way, he's top 300 currently and trending upwards by all accounts. Wouldn't call that a poor rating. Let's see how his offer list and ranking looks after his SR year and we can revisit.

You've posted 3 Harry Potter novels in this thread, compared to my singular follow-up post attempting to address your comments. But keep yelling at the sky, maybe someone will listen!
Posted by NotaStarGazer
Member since Dec 2023
1186 posts
Posted on 3/11/24 at 8:20 pm to
The fact that it is my opinion is subjective not objective. I gave a subjective analysis of Ross' ability and once again say he won't start a game for LSU in his career.
1) I didn't criticize his offers being less than 125. Where in the world you got that I guess you just made it up. What I said was his offers were poor. He basically has no impressive offers other than LSU....period! Your projection of his growth of offers is subjective opinion on your part...no proof whatsoever.
2) Recruiting services hit on a lot more than they miss on. I assume you have seen the 5* and 4* numbers eventually getting to the NFL. As my userid implies, that is not the be all and end all but I never said the services were idiots.
3) Dave Campbell's site has a pretty good track record
4) No one has supplied cherry-picked HS coaches opinions but I'm sure they are coming. Those opinions need to be shared with major colleges who are ignoring the guy
Once again, I am projecting my opinion on Charles Ross. I have stated from day 1 that he is worth a scholarship but some posters have him in the top 50 in his class. Thus, what is the difference between me projecting my opinion and they projecting theirs?
You made a statement that he is "trending upwards by all accounts". Exactly what accounts are those?
BTW, I said I would end my posting on this thread. Then the original poster included my name in the title and others started posting directly towards me. Want to end the dead horse beating. Simple suggestion: we call all stop posting on this thread. Otherwise, it is hypocritical to say it is me continuing this deal.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 1Next pagelast page
refresh

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram