re: Which Singer Does the Best 'O Holy Night'?

I love the Mathis rendition. My mom had the original album and it was always on the record player during the Christmas holidays when I was a child. I inherited all of her albums when she passed and that one now gets played on my record player during the holidays.

But I had never heard the David Phelps rendition until this thread and I am in awe after watching the video. Johnny for sentimental reasons but Phelps is the most powerful and moving I have ever heard.