Deer rifle for slight 15 year old girl

My girls are smaller than yours and they shoot a 7mm-08 and stack deer up like cord wood

This is the correct answer. 7mm-08 with Reduced Recoil ammo for training and full loads for hunting.

Both Daughters have hunted since they were 9 and 10. Both have shot a .270 since day one. Don't over think it. They both shoot a scoped .22 or a .22 magnum for practice and I let them each shoot the .270 once for confidence before season. They have never mentioned anymore than the gun is just loud.

Yeah, I got my sons in 7mm08 and took him to the range when he was 7. He never stopped smiling. I put him on the .22 for about 100 rounds.

A 7 yo is a hell of a lot steadier than a 46 year old!

He killed one deer with it at 7 and 2 hogs and 1 deer last year. All good shots, hope he continues his good shooting.

quote:

---

but I think it’s underpowered

---

Well, you're wrong so...

ETA: If you shoot a deer in the right spot, the .243 is perfectly fine. People think you have to have a bigger gun for knockdown power, but the fact is, a deer can run off from a bad shot with any gun.

quote:

---

but the fact is, a deer can run off from a bad shot with any gun.

---

And kids make more bad shots than adults, therefore a bigger piece of lead making a bigger hole is better if they can handle the gun.

my daughter is 10 and very skinny and has been shooting a ruger american compact .308 with regular 150 grain winchester power point bullets for 2 years now with no issues. Just let her practice plinking with a .22 and get her used to finding things in the scope with the .22. Put the deer rifle in her hands come deer season and she wont even notice the kick when she shoots at a deer. My daughter has killed 4 deer and about a dozen hogs with the .308 and never ever mentioned it kicked or hurt to shoot. I started her with a .243 and never again. People believe a .243 is good bc it has low recoil which is true but imo it is a better gun for an adult who is more skilled in shot placement than a kid bc it doesnt leave a kid much room for error. Something like a .308 gives a kid a little more room for error and leaves better blood trails and I know kids need to practice and if they do a .243 is fine blah blah blah but in reality when a buck walks out in front of a child they get nervous and often make imperfect shots and i much rather a cartridge that is more forgiving than a .243.

quote:

---

I've tracked more .243 shot deer than I can count. Pretty often they are excellent shots that dont exit. frick a .243

---

Not doubting you, although "more than I can count" seems like a bit of an exaggeration. I will say that the bullet can make a huge difference. For instance, IMO an 80 grain ballistic tip at 3300 fps has a very low chance of exiting a big buck that was shot square in the shoulder. But I've seen the same ammo blow a hole the size of your fist when exiting a smaller deer. The BIL I mentioned in my post shoots 100 grain Remington Core Lokt and gets good exits on some really nice south Texas bucks.

Really cant recall how many it's been. The dog is 9 years old now.

Itll get the job done for sure and an experienced shooter will do fine with it. I dont like seeing a kid use it. A 7mm-08 or one of the 6.5's gives a much wider margin for error with negligible increase in recoil.