- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
How was defensive holding not called on the fake punt?
Posted on 12/8/19 at 5:54 pm
Posted on 12/8/19 at 5:54 pm
Still haven’t gotten an explanation on that one
NFL just praying that kind of goes away and doesn’t get any press
NFL just praying that kind of goes away and doesn’t get any press
7
Posted on 12/8/19 at 5:55 pm to PhillyTiger90
They said that because it’s a punt, the receiver is not a receiver so PI rules do not apply
Posted on 12/8/19 at 5:56 pm to PhillyTiger90
Idk. I understand it not being dpi being that it was a punting situation but it's still a penalty to hold the gunner.
Posted on 12/8/19 at 5:57 pm to Laaz2750
quote:
They said that because it’s a punt, the receiver is not a receiver so PI rules do not apply
Yes but holding is still in play. Flags are thrown all the time for holding against the gunner.
Posted on 12/8/19 at 5:57 pm to Laaz2750
Holding =\= DPI
They could have and should have called holding. But they didn't and a no-call of holding is not reviewable.
They could have and should have called holding. But they didn't and a no-call of holding is not reviewable.
Posted on 12/8/19 at 5:58 pm to PhillyTiger90
Technically it was holding, but the reality is that hand fighting and that kind of contact occurs on every punt play and never gets called.
Posted on 12/8/19 at 5:59 pm to Laaz2750
quote:
They said that because it’s a punt, the receiver is not a receiver so PI rules do not apply
He didn’t ask why PI wasn’t called...
Posted on 12/8/19 at 5:59 pm to SD Tider
That was more than hand fighting. The 49ers player had Smith by the shoulder pad.
quote:
and never gets called.
This post was edited on 12/8/19 at 6:02 pm
Posted on 12/8/19 at 5:59 pm to Hangover Haven
Fair enough
Posted on 12/8/19 at 6:00 pm to PhillyTiger90
They held the saints gunner.
Posted on 12/8/19 at 6:00 pm to PhillyTiger90
Was still a stupid play call by CSP.
Fake punt on 4th and 13 or something like that.
Fake punt on 4th and 13 or something like that.
Posted on 12/8/19 at 6:01 pm to SD Tider
The 49er grabbed him by the jersey and drove him out of bounds
It was not pass interference but no question it was holding
They blew it
It was not pass interference but no question it was holding
They blew it
Posted on 12/8/19 at 6:03 pm to BigBrod81
Idk. I understand it not being dpi being that it was a punting situation but it's still a penalty to hold the gunner.
yes but it wasnt called and you cant challenge and review holding
its infuriating but i look and point to payton there to blame on that. he drew up a play using a man who was going to be hand checking the whole way down field and yet he didnt realize 9 out of 10 times the guy will be getting mugged with no penalty and no chance to catch the ball.
taysom should have taken off and run since we only needed a few yards and he most likely would have gotten the first down but payton was hoping to get a penalty on a guy that was immune from getting a flag thrown in that spot 
yes but it wasnt called and you cant challenge and review holding
its infuriating but i look and point to payton there to blame on that. he drew up a play using a man who was going to be hand checking the whole way down field and yet he didnt realize 9 out of 10 times the guy will be getting mugged with no penalty and no chance to catch the ball.
taysom should have taken off and run since we only needed a few yards and he most likely would have gotten the first down but payton was hoping to get a penalty on a guy that was immune from getting a flag thrown in that spot
Posted on 12/8/19 at 6:14 pm to SD Tider
Why is it when it's something that would benefit the Saints it's -
But when it's something that hurts the Saints, it's -
The problem is an inordinate amount of close calls and judgment calls always go against the Saints and never the opponent. There are stats that bear this out that were posted last week on Saints talk.
quote:
Technically it was holding, but... occurs on every punt play and never gets called.
But when it's something that hurts the Saints, it's -
quote:
bUt MUH unNEceSsarY rOuGHnEsS aGaInsT CGJ oN Juszczyk WuZ tEcHnICallY coRreCt sO StoP CrYiNg
The problem is an inordinate amount of close calls and judgment calls always go against the Saints and never the opponent. There are stats that bear this out that were posted last week on Saints talk.
This post was edited on 12/8/19 at 6:16 pm
Posted on 12/8/19 at 6:16 pm to PhillyTiger90
You're not allowed to call penalties on a fake punt. Anything goes. That's what the NFL said.
This post was edited on 12/8/19 at 6:35 pm
Posted on 12/8/19 at 6:18 pm to keakar
Ultimately, calling the deep ball outside there is bad game planning by the nature of the rules.
Posted on 12/8/19 at 6:36 pm to Hulkklogan
Not only that miss but in the first half on a third down play in SF territory their LT false started
The PFM on Gardner Johnson was such Bulls hit. I mean, the FB could still get up....the guy is a football player
The PFM on Gardner Johnson was such Bulls hit. I mean, the FB could still get up....the guy is a football player
Posted on 12/8/19 at 7:19 pm to KiwiHead
...and then they DO call penalty against Chauncy for what was nothing more than a "football play" no helmet to helmet
Posted on 12/8/19 at 7:21 pm to SD Tider
Smith almost made a Prothro catch, which when a play call relies on that is stupid.
Posted on 12/8/19 at 7:33 pm to PhillyTiger90
I think even if holding was called it would have been a 10 yard penalty to back the 49ers up. Not a 1st down for the Saints.
Page 1 of 1
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News