re: Knock at the Cabin

quote:

---

It's horrific. I've never been as mad at a movie in my life when Marky Mark slipped beneath the waves at the end realizing the entire story was a fabrication.

---

This thread has now told me that The Perfect Storm and Signs are both terrible. Those are two excellent movies.

I get what you mean about TPS...I was unfamiliar with the story and so I was expecting a bit of a different ending, but it's a movie and I took it as much.

quote:

---

He thinks outside the box

---

unfortunately that box is also in another box

quote:

---

Ehh movie was alright. I lost my shite a couple of times. The world would be gone cause of me..

---

Watching it now. Decent enough movie, but I lost my shite when he ran to the truck and to get the gun in the safe and it wasn't loaded, not were the any rounds in the mag. Why carry a gun then?

quote:

---

it wasn't loaded, not were the any rounds in the mag. Why carry a gun then?

---

I thought the movie made it pretty clear that he was gay.

I watched it last night and thought it was very well done - very suspenseful and great cinematography. Agreed about the ending - but just not sure what could have been done.

I liked that it more or less had unity of time and place. And the effects of the disasters - it was cool how they gave just tangential exposure to that.

This was his best in a long time. I liked Old, but pretty much nothing else since The Village.

quote:

---

I get what you mean about TPS...I was unfamiliar with the story and so I was expecting a bit of a different ending, but it's a movie and I took it as much.

---

i completely agree with him (not that it was bad, but about the story. This was overly advertised as "Based on a true story". The only thing true about the story was there was a boat that went out and didnt come back.

None of the parts of the story were "true" that happened on the boat.