Started By
Message

Which NFL Draft had the worst QB class?

Posted on 5/3/20 at 5:28 am
Posted by saintsfan92612
Taiwan
Member since Oct 2008
28830 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 5:28 am
I think it is either 1996 or 2007. Both of them were quite horrid when you look at the numbers. 1996 which had no first round QBs and just two QBs taken in the first 3 rounds or 2007 which had 2 first round QBs who busted spectacularly?

1996
42nd pick - STL- Tony Banks - 77TDs, 73 Ints, 73 fumbles, 72.4 Rating, 35-43 record as a starter
85th pick - PHI - Bobby Hoying - 11 TDs, 15 INTs, 64.3 Rating, 3-9-1 record as a starter
100th pick - DEN - Jeff Lewis - no starts/out of the league by 2000 0 TDs, 2 INTs
130th pick - NYG - Danny Kanell - 31Tds, 34 Ints, 63.2 Rating, 10-13-1 record as a starter
203rd pick - PIT -Spence Fishcer - didn't make team
205th pick - IND - Mike Cawley - didn't make team, was a backup in CFL and XFL
238th pick - BAL - Jon Stark - never played/suspended from NFL for betting on games
240th pick - GB- Kyle Wachholtz- didn't make team



No QB taken until #42. Only 8 QBs were taken in the draft. Only 3 of them ever started an NFL game: Tony Banks, Bobby Hoying, and Danny Kanell. They would go a combined 48-65-2 as starters. 3/8 didn't make the team their rookie years. 2 of them made the team but never started including Stark who was basically banned from the NFL for gambling during his rookie season.

2007
1st pick - OAK - JaMarcus Russell - 18 TDs, 23 INTs, 25 fumbles, 65.2 rating, 7-18 record as a starter
22nd pick - CLE - Brady Quinn - 12 TDs, 17 INTs, 64.4 rating, 4-16 record as a starter
36th pick - PHI - Kevin Kolb - 28 TDs, 25 INts, 78.9 rating, 9-12 record as a starter
40th pick - MIA - John Beck - 3 TDs, 7 Ints, 10 fumbles, 67.6 rating, 0-7 record as a starter
43rd pick - DET - Drew Stanton - 20 TDs, 24 INTs, 66.3 rating, 11-6 record as a starter
92nd pick - BUF - Trent Edwards - 26 TDs, 30 INTs, 75.5 rating, 14-19 record as a starter
151st pick - CIN - Jeff Rowe - made team as rookie, never played
174th pick - BAL - Troy Smith - 8 TDs, 5 INTs, 9 fumbles, 78.5 rating, 4-4 record as a starter
205th pick - WAS - Jordan Palmer - 0 TDs, 2 INTs, 28.7 rating, never started a game
217th pick - MIN - Tyler Thigpen - 21 TDs, 18 INTs, 72.5 rating, 1-11 record as a starter

So a lot more "success" here overall, with every player making a roster. No QB started more than 33 career games. No pro-bowl appearances. Combined 50-93 record as starters. Possibly biggest bust in NFL history.

Is there another QB class that was worse than these two?
This post was edited on 5/3/20 at 5:31 am
Posted by lsusteltz16
LaGrange, Ga
Member since Nov 2007
876 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 5:37 am to
2013:

Ej Manuel
Geno Smith
Mike glennon
Landry Jones
Matt Barkley
Posted by saintsfan92612
Taiwan
Member since Oct 2008
28830 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 5:47 am to
yeah, 2013 deserves to be in the conversation for sure. As well as 1997.
Posted by Powerman
Member since Jan 2004
162190 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 5:52 am to
quote:

As well as 1997

Just looked and you're right. Jake Plummer was the only one with any sort of NFL success at all
Posted by GetCocky11
Calgary, AB
Member since Oct 2012
51235 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 6:16 am to
quote:

238th pick - BAL - Jon Stark


had a nice 2nd career as the King in the North
Posted by Jack Daniel
In the bottle
Member since Feb 2013
25408 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 7:36 am to
Christian Ponder was in that draft as well, right?
Posted by Hamma1122
Member since Sep 2016
19802 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 8:26 am to
2013
Posted by SeeeeK
some where
Member since Sep 2012
28026 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 8:27 am to
quote:

STL- Tony Banks


NO ONE and i mean NO ONE, not Brady, Manning, Montana, Marino, NO ONE threw a better 3rd and long, 3 yard out, into the sidelines, like Tony.

He made sure on 3rd and 8, that only you could catch that 3 yard out, and you couldn't get more than the 3 yards, as you tippy toed the line before falling out of bounds.

I bet his completion % rate on those 3rd and longs for 3-4 yards was in the 98's. Touchdown Tony, he's so missed.
Posted by lepdagod
Baton Rouge
Member since Jan 2015
3358 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 8:55 am to
quote:

Ej Manuel Geno Smith Mike glennon Landry Jones Matt Barkley


Winner...Winner

Posted by lepdagod
Baton Rouge
Member since Jan 2015
3358 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 8:56 am to
quote:

Christian Ponder


The most baffling decision in the history of human decision making...
Posted by FightinTigersDammit
Louisiana North
Member since Mar 2006
34581 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 9:19 am to
quote:

Geno Smith


Had his jaw broken by a teammate.
Posted by Lester Earl
Member since Nov 2003
278148 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 9:44 am to
2010

Bradford
Tebow
Clausen
Colt McCoy
Kafka
Skelton
Crompton
LeFevour
Pike
Brown
Canfield
Taylor

Posted by sunnydaze
Member since Jan 2010
29939 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 10:00 am to
At least Bradford made a shite ton of money
Posted by Bestbank Tiger
Premium Member
Member since Jan 2005
70838 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 10:20 am to
2002. Hide your eyes:

2002
1st: David Carr: Fresno State: Houston Texans
3rd: Joey Harrington: Oregon: Detroit Lions
32nd: Patrick Ramsey: Tulane: Washington Redskins
81st: Josh McCown: Sam Houston State: Arizona Cardinals
108th: David Garrard: East Carolina: Jacksonville Jaguars
117th: Rohan Davey: LSU: New England Patriots
137th: Randy Fasani: Stanford: Carolina Panthers
158th: Kurt Kittner: Illinois: Atlanta Falcons
163rd: Brandon Doman: Brigham Young: San Francisco 49ers
164th: Craig Nall: Northwestern State: Green Bay Packers
186th: J.T. O'Sullivan: UC Davis: New Orleans Saints
205th: Steve Bellisari: Ohio State: Saint Louis Rams
216th: Seth Burford: Cal Poly SLO
232nd: Jeff Kelly: Southern Mississippi: Seattle Seahawks
236th: Wes Pate: Stephen F. Austin: Baltimore Ravens
Posted by Diseasefreeforall
Member since Oct 2012
5481 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 10:28 am to
quote:

Trent Edwards

Bills fans used to call him Trentative because he was so afraid to make mistakes. He even moved to Buffalo with his sister because he wasn't comfortable on his own.

This post was edited on 5/3/20 at 10:29 am
Posted by Jack Daniel
In the bottle
Member since Feb 2013
25408 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 10:29 am to
Taking a QB in the first round doesn’t make him a first round talent but some GM’s think it’s a magical pill.
Posted by SpartyGator
Detroit Lions fan
Member since Oct 2011
75336 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 10:33 am to
quote:

David Carr:
just got sacked again
Posted by TheeRealCarolina
Member since Aug 2018
17925 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 10:40 am to
Christian Ponder was in the 2011 draft. That was the first draft with the new rookie salary cap rules and we were coming off of a holdout so a lot of teams over drafted QBs because of how relatively cheap their contracts were - Gabbert, Locker, and Ponder being among them. Hell even guys like Dalton, Mallet, and He Who Should Not Be Named, were drafted 2-3 rounds ahead of where they normally would have been because of the new contracts.

Oddly enough, the QB taken in that draft with the best chance to start a regular season game this year is the second to the last QB taken.
Posted by dukke v
PLUTO
Member since Jul 2006
202580 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 10:47 am to
That draft was horrible.
Posted by KCM0Tiger
Kansas City, MISSOURI
Member since Nov 2011
15511 posts
Posted on 5/3/20 at 11:01 am to
quote:

2013:

Ej Manuel
Geno Smith
Mike glennon
Landry Jones
Matt Barkley


Yup I came here to say this. Of course that was the only year in Chiefs history we had the #1 pick.

It all worked out for the best though
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram