re: LHSAA Playoff baseball brackets released

quote:

---

So St Charles Catholic wins DII championship in 2019, and then moves down because they lost 12 seniors and complained about enrollment dropping and losing kids to Destrahan, moves down to DIII, wins their district and is now playing for the DIII Title?

---

sounds like they dropped down from 3A to 2A like a hundred other schools before them

quote:

---

Pretty sure if they win the division with Catholic, Jesuit, and John Curtis, they’d have a chance in 5A

---

Barbe laughs at this.

quote:

---

Barbe laughs at this.

---

Last 10 titles in combined 5a:

4 for privates (Catholic and Jesuit)

6 for publics(Barbe and northshore)

So yeh, I think winning D1 holds some weight

quote:

---

like a hundred other schools before them

---

Name the ones that won a state title in a higher class one year and the very next year dropped to a lower class and are competing for another title in that lower class all while the higher class they were in is having a down year.

If st charles moved down then why didn’t De La Salle?

quote:

---

LHSAA Playoff baseball brackets released
So we ruined everything for 2 schools

---

due to the 7 that sent them down..if you call this ruined...

many are happy

quote:

---

Why are they afraid to compete with Vandy, Ed White, Parkview, Teurlings, UHigh?

Instead they rather play Newman?

---

and in football they had to deal with LCA....

quote:

---

Last 10 titles in combined 5a:

4 for privates (Catholic and Jesuit)

6 for publics(Barbe and northshore)

So yeh, I think winning D1 holds some weight

---

So Barbe won as many titles or more as everyone in D1 combined during that span. So how was my statement not true? Barbe is the standard for Louisiana baseball.

quote:

---

What do you mean “it sounds like”. That’s exactly what I said

Why are they afraid to compete with Vandy, Ed White, Parkview, Teurlings, UHigh?

Instead they rather play Newman?

---

I’ll never begrudge a school for playing where their enrollment says they should

quote:

---

I’ll never begrudge a school for playing where their enrollment says they should

---

Then you wouldn’t have a problem with JC and Evangel playing Div III?

quote:

---

I’ll never begrudge a school for playing where their enrollment says they should

---

Which is exactly why we have the split. those 1A for 3A schools are still sour from the "play in class years" of course ECA is nothing like they were.... but still unlike nearly everyone in their class. for 99% enrollment is a good barometer.... it's the 1%.