Which group of 10 players would you rather land. Just including the 'big' dogs. Just doing it because me and a buddy are having an argument

Class 1 (3 5*s....7 4*s)
RB- Leonard Fournette *****
OL- Garrett Brumfield ****
DB- Tony Brown *****
DB- Ed Paris ****
DB- Laurence 'Hootie' Jones ****
WR- Trey Quinn ****
WR- D'haquille Williams *****
WR- Cameron Sims ****
DL- Gerald Willis III ****
LB- Kenny Young ****

Class 2 (6 5*s....4 4*s)
RB- Racean 'Roc' Thomas ****
OL- Cam Robinson *****
DB- Jabrill Peppers *****
DB- Adoree Jackson *****
WR- Malachi Dupre ****
WR- Speedy Noil *****
WR- Saeed Blacknall ****
DL- Lorenzo Carter *****
DL- Davon Godchaux ****
LB- Clifton Garrett *****

Class 2 is clearly stronger throughout but would you be willing to give up the monsters (LF, Tony and D'haquille)

9 ...

Report Post

Posted by OMFGKenny

Boothville-Venice

Member since Jan 2013

960 posts

Posted on 5/20/13 at 1:23 am to Tigah32

Class 2 by far. You are giving up LF but getting CRob, Garrett, Lorenzo Carter, Jabrill, and Adoree' Jackson makes up for it. Imo.

This post was edited on 5/20/13 at 1:24 am

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by Section225

Member since Jun 2011

3737 posts

Posted on 5/20/13 at 1:33 am to OMFGKenny

This is a crappy thing to do ... hahaha

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by Datbayoubengal

Port City

Member since Sep 2009

29337 posts

Posted on 5/20/13 at 3:02 am to Tigah32

I'd have to go class 2. Even though you can't take LF, you get a downright ridiculous defense, prototypical LSU WRs, and no slouch of a RB either in Roc.

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by kevlanmei

New Taipei City (Tamsui)

Member since Jul 2011

975 posts

Posted on 5/20/13 at 6:25 am to Tigah32

Seriously, it's not even close. Give me Class #2 all day long. Now, if you add Cam Robinson and Malachi Dupre to Class #1 (in exchange for Quinn Kenny Young), it might be more of a toss-up.

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by fightingtigers98

Member since Oct 2011

13303 posts

Posted on 5/20/13 at 6:56 am to Tigah32

LF>>Roc
GB<CR
Brown<<Peppers
Paris<Jackson
Quinn<Dupre
DW>>Noil
Sims<Blacknall
GW3>Carter
KY<Garrett

by my calculations class 2, but i really want class 1

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by brewhan davey

Audubon Place

Member since Sep 2010

33373 posts

Posted on 5/20/13 at 7:19 am to Tigah32

Try this again without including 3 of our commits in one of your groupings. That can only make for bad answers by people picking against them.

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by Weaver

Madisonville, LA

Member since Nov 2005

28126 posts

Posted on 5/20/13 at 8:14 am to Tigah32

I have a want for both.

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by Ac16

Birmingham

Member since Jun 2011

808 posts

Posted on 5/20/13 at 9:18 am to fightingtigers98

quote:
Brown<<Peppers

Negative

quote:
GB<CR

Different positions

This post was edited on 5/20/13 at 9:19 am

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by UncleRuckus

Member since Feb 2013

10100 posts

Posted on 5/20/13 at 9:26 am to Tigah32

I'd take 1. Get the best player in the country.
Brown and Paris =adoree and peppers
Get the best wr of the bunch plus Quinn who I really like.
Brumfield, hootie, Sims, GW, and young are pretty damn good also.

Thankfully we can take 25 and should get a very large share of the 20 guys listed

1 ...

Report Post

Posted by VermilionTiger

Member since Dec 2012

39274 posts

Posted on 5/20/13 at 9:33 am to Tigah32

Not seeing your point, unless you're just having fun

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by Datbayoubengal

Port City

Member since Sep 2009

29337 posts

Posted on 5/20/13 at 11:14 am to UncleRuckus

quote:
Get the best wr of the bunch plus Quinn who I really like.

you get the best for one year

IMO
Dupre, Blacknall, Noil>>> D'haquille (1yr), Sims, Quinn

0 ...

Report Post

Posted by Tigah32

Baton Rouge

Member since Oct 2010

5721 posts

Posted on 5/20/13 at 2:09 pm to Tigah32

I would take class 1. The only big push for me would be Cam Robinson but look at the 04-09 class recruits. (Last 5 draft classes)

5 Star Olineman
Jeff Byers
Thomas Herring
Eugene Monroe - Panned Out
Reginald Youngblood
Alex Boone
Dan Doering
Andre Smith - Panned Out
Sam Young
Stephen Schilling
Josh Oglesby
Tray Allen
Ryan Miller
Kristofer O'Dowd
Mike Adams - Panned Out
Baker Steinkuhler
Matt Kalil - Panned Out
Michael Brewster
Tyron Smith - Panned Out
Matt Patchan
Stephen Good
Tyler Love
DJ Fluker - Panned Out
Mason Walters

That's 6 out of 23 that panned out. Then you look at guys like Lane Johnson (unranked) or Eric Fisher (2 star)

In Class 1 you have Leonard who's the biggest running back prospect since Adrian (likely the 3rd best RB of all time) and he fits an incredibly large need.

Leonard >>> Roc
Brumfield < Cam Robinson
Tony Brown, Laurence Jones, Ed Paris > Peppers, Adoree'
Trey Quinn, D'haquille(1 year), Sims < Malachi, Speedy, Blacknall
Gerald Willis << Lorenzo, Davon
Kenny Young = Clifton Garrett

IMHO I would rather the kids from the southern states (Tony, Trey, Hootie and Kenny), especially Louisiana kids, than kids that dominate lesser talent in the north/northeast/west (Peppers, Blacknall, Adoree', Clifton)

Page 1