NFL top QB's...

awful

quote:

---

NFL top QB's...
1.Tom Brady
1a.Peyton Manning
2. Ben Rothlisberger
3. Kurt Warner
4. Drew Brees
5. Phillip Rivers
6. Tony Romo
7. A Rodgers
8. Matt Cassel
9. Matt Ryan
10.D McNabb

---

He blows. If you replace him with half the guys on the list they do the same thing as far as SBs. He had the 24th best QB rating, 21st best completion percentage, 14th most yards, 17th yards/game, 15th in TDs, and 4th in Int last season. He was 17/15 Td/Int last season. He is average at best. The fact people are saying he could go to the HOF for his SBs makes me want to

quote:

---

dezenutz

---

quote:

---

dezenutz

---

for stupid thread and horrible list

quote:

---

lsutiger2486

---

for probably the most ridiculously intellectually devoid statement in football history

quote:

---

Ben Rothlisberger He blows

---

Wow, you are just daft. Go back to playing Hello Kitty's Island Adventure

I guess Ill do one. Frick it.

1. Tom Brady
2. Peyton Manning
3. Drew Brees
4. Kurt Warner
5. Ben Roethlisberger
6. Jay Cutler
7. Philip Rivers
8. Tony Romo
9. Eli Manning
10.Carson Palmer

Flame away.

I'm going to side with the thread starter here a bit. Whether you agree with his list or not... he posted his opinion and nobody else has had the balls to put their own list together and make the tough calls. I'd imagine its not easy once you get past 4 or 5.

But here's my thoughts, my list is really the list of qb's i'd want on my team moving forward:

1) Tom Brady
2) Peyton Manning
3) Drew Brees
4) Phillip Rivers- Dude is a great passer, a good leader, very passionate, young and still can get better.
5) Tony Romo- I think Tony is a fantastic player. He's only been playing a couple years in a circus called Dallas Cowboys. You put Romo with a coach and or organization like Belichek or Payton or somewhere else with a stable team and I think Romo does even better.
6) Matt Ryan- Upside is amazing and he played incredible as a rookie. Could be top 3 in a year.
7) Jay Cutler- He's been an excellent player. Worried about some off field issues but on the field, he's been a fantastic qb.
8) Ben Roethlisberger- Could make an argument he can be higher but the dude just wins. Yes he's been on good teams but he's also made clutch plays.
9) Eli Manning- Pretty good qb, lacks some team leadership but has developed pretty nice. Doesn't always have the efficient qb numbers.
10) Aaron Rogers- Quietly played very well last year and since he's young and has very little tread on his tires, he should be very productive for years to come.

Next tier: Matt Cassell, Kurt Warner (getting old so i left him out), Pennington, McNabb

I don't know what to make of Carson Palmer. You would think his leadership would have been established in Cincy and he would run that team but he hasn't and that worries me.

quote:

---

your list is shite. Mcnabb is better than half the douchebags you have on that list. nice job queen....

---

Where's you list tough guy? And you can have your 32 year old career 58% completion passer and 85 passer rating douche of a qb.

There's no way Romo is only two spots down from Brees.

Brady is NOT consensus #1 either.

1.Drew Brees
2.Tom Brady
3.Kurt Warner
4.Peyton Manning
5.Aaron Rodgers
6.Tony Romo
7.Philip Rivers
8.Donovan McNabb
9.Matt Ryan
10.Matt Cassel
11.Jay Cutler

Was on sportscenter this morning.

LINK